Back to Iona: more work and more play...
Posted: Monday, 14 May 2007 |
Comments
James / MM - your posts here have been an absolute inspiration. Mr T and I holiday on Mull as often as possible, and I'll be looking at the island in a new light after seeing your photographs. I have yet to get Mr T to Iona but it's an absolute must for our next visit.
Mrs Trellis from North Wales
Great pics again, James, and fascinating content as usual. How interesting the landscape must be to you with your geological knowledge. I note also that you are a computer expert - you sound like a useful kinda guy to have around! Thanks again.
Jill from EK
MM, I can see big things for you, how about The New Weir's Way Man? Come on the viewing public are crying out for your sort of thing, if you do become the New Weirs Way ( although maybe a title change would be in order, don't disturb me, I'm thinking拢拢拢拢拢拢拢拢拢, Right how about A Stroll With James, or The Mountain Man of Mull, or Rock With James,) I think a 15% finders fee would be in order, but I'm willing to accept 10%.
Thewhitesettler from Agents Den
Actually, the point that Thewhitesettler raises is a good one. Geology is a seriously under -represented subject, considering its importance, esp in Scotland. If you go to the www.scottishgeology.com website and look for the list of famous Scots geologists, it is quite mind boggling. I am sure that a very good series of TV programmes could be made, visiting differnet places and describing the landscape, geology, economic impact, legacy to science etc. Trouble is, geology is a bit of a Cinderella subject - it doesnt quite have the impact that say wildlife does. Trying to make it sexy and fun takes a lot of work!
James (MM) from Tobermory
here was i thinking poor soul away working again! Less sympathy from now on!
Moira (Mountainmans wife!) from Tobermory
I've got a new one for you, how about, " The Scots Geology Story With James From Tobermory" ( I'd watch the programme, oh there was a prog. on last thursday on 91热爆2, 6pm, the Gaellic progs. and they were in Skye, hill walking, and although the weather was rotten, it was still an enjoyable show )
Thewhitesettler from Upintheclouds
That TV series about Britain by Alan Titchmarsh touched on geology quite a lot. He went to that site in WRoss (can't remember the name) where important geological discoveries were first formulated (at least that's what it says at the Visitor Centre), and he also explained the underlying geology in several locations e.g. the Yorkshire Dales etc. Not enough, though, I agree! A fascinating subject, and one that is all around us, wherever we live.
Jill from EK
James/MM Fascinating stuff having the landscape (in this case one I know fairly well) 'read' for us by someone with your knowledge and understanding. Thankyou. While we are on an Iona theme can you comment on the geological origins/causes of Iona marble? You may have seen the old quarry that, from memory, is a bit further south west from the bay in the Eilean Carrach picture. I still carry a small piece of Iona marble with me when sailing because legend has it that you will never drown if you have it on you. Not sure if the Ausssie Gods - if they exist - would be influenced by that myth.
Guy from Australia
Guy, the Celtic giant who made the basalt columns seems to have been to Australia, so your bit of marble should work OK. I wouldn't rely on it entirely, though, make sure your boat is OK too!
Jill from EK
Guy, Re the Iona marble - I had heard of the legend about it that you will never drown if you have a bit on you. Presumably not a LARGE lump of it... ! Its one of my favourite bits of rock (apart from UFO's Rock Bottom...) It would have started off as a limestone or chalk, very pure and has been metamorphosed by heat and presusre a very long time ago. The Lewisian rocks, of which it is part, are over 2000 million years old. It would have been deposited as a sedimentary rock originally, just like much younger limestones and chalk that you get in lots of other places. What that particular landscape looked like is anyones guess - some sort of lagoonal conditions I would imagine. The green streaking in it is serpentine, which would have formed from the small amounts of impurities and other thin sedimentary layers in the original rock. Interestingly the really green variety is only found as pebbles at St Columbas Bay and other such places - it is reckoned to be derived from an undersea extension of the exisitng marble at the quarry - nowhere has it been found in situ. There is also another marble to be found west of Dun Chul Bhuirg on the west coast - here it is a grey-green silvery rock known as "Silverstone" Quite unlike the stuff from the quarry. There are other marble seams as well. The best documented information on all this is the Memoir of the Geological Survey for the area, published in 1925 but now way out of print. It is however available as a photocopy reprint from the BGS - see my links on the right. There is a lot of info and a map showing the various locations. Sometimes confused with the marble is a rock referred to as the "White Rock" - this is a thing called anorthosite, a fairly rare type of rock. Anorthosite is found in Harris and is what the super-quarry was to be dug into. It also makes up a lot of the Moon. The Iona "White Rock" occurs near to the marble quarry but is much harder - it extends way inland. The marble on the other hand only outcrops over a relatively short distance.
James (Mountainman) from Tobermory
Thanks James. I don't want to get in Moira's bad books but next time you are on Iona visit the Martyrs Bay bar and tell my brother Gordon Grant who owns it you have been educating me on-line and as a result I owe you a dram that you want to collect from him!
Guy from Australia
Guy. Sounds alright to me! I havent seen Gordon for a wee while, but I do go into the Martyr's Bay Restaurant regularly - its a good place (hope I am not breaking the IB rules on commercial advertising here....) Next time I see him, I'll let him know! Cheers! MM
James (MM) from Tobermory
Interesting shots and comments. Thanks.
mjc from NM,USA
Dear MM - I have a beautiful piece of "green granite" from Iona. Best described as of-white stone that has had a green colour wash added all over. I have a photo of it which I could email to you and would really welcome your help in identifying its name and history. Kind regards. Ann Banks
annb4banks from Birmingham