Our favourite armchair adventure stories are revealed
22 April 2021
Familiar tales by Robert Louis Stevenson, Enid Blyton and Jules Verne remain popular, and the off-world destinations of Douglas Adams and Terry Pratchett exert a pull on readers, but hobbits and wizards dominate people's favourite adventure stories on a new list released to mark World Book Night 2021.
Many of us have turned to our bookshelves since lockdowns began to curtail our leisure activities, in pursuit of writing that allows us to travel vicariously. Almost a third of people started reading more last year, according to The Reading Agency. And capturing a sense of excitement and escape is a powerful reason to pick up a novel.
New research by the University of Wolverhampton sheds light on what motivates readers to seek out adventure stories. As part of an ongoing study for the 91热爆’s The Novels That Shaped Our World project, participants were asked to identify the adventure stories that had shaped them.
The research team noticed two clear trends after studying more than 3000 recommendations from 1500 participants.
Getting lost in large worlds
The range of book recommendations spans historical periods, from H. Rider Haggard’s Victorian tales of explorer Allan Quatermain to Terry Pratchett’s hugely influential Discworld series.
The prevalence of trilogies and series connects many of these disparate stories. Of the 11 most popular authors chosen by readers, only Robert Louis Stevenson and Jules Verne were best known for their standalone novels. The other nine writers all created well-loved worlds that they revisited in sequels or epic series.
Readers’ reasons for nominating those particular books were revealing. We might think of adventure stories as simple tales of good and evil, yet many reported that they were drawn to rich and complex worlds in order to explore difficult choices and moral complexities.
The appeal of familiar characters was also important. One participant described returning to the real world, after completing a favourite adventure series, as 'like losing a friend'.
Popular adventure writers
The 11 most popular adventure writers, as chosen by our survey participants:
- Douglas Adams
- Enid Blyton
- Frank Herbert
- C. S. Lewis
- Terry Pratchett
- Philip Pullman
- Arthur Ransome
- J. K. Rowling
- Robert Louis Stevenson
- J.R.R. Tolkien
- Jules Verne
The enduring appeal of children’s stories
Another striking feature of the participants’ recommendations was the high percentage of children’s stories. Peter Pan, Alice in Wonderland, the Lemony Snicket novels and the Artemis Fowl series were all chosen as favourites by adult readers.
The researchers were able to divide respondents by age, and this produced interesting results. Some children’s books, such as the stories of action hero , were more popular with the over-50s. However, Chronicles of Narnia by C.S. Lewis and Enid Blyton’s Famous Five and Secret Seven books were favoured by younger adults, suggesting these stories have found new generations of fans.
Again, readers’ reasons for choosing titles were illuminating. One respondent described how Peter Pan and Alice in Wonderland had shaped their imagination and inspired them to become more resilient. Another reported that Arthur Ransome’s Swallows and Amazons had inspired a life-long love of camping trips.
Clear favourites
Notwithstanding the very wide range of books recommended by participants, two authors stood out from the crowd. J. K. Rowling’s Harry Potter series was one clear favourite, but was beaten into second place by J.R.R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings. Despite being published over sixty years ago, it was also most popular among younger readers.
Of course, Rowling’s and Tolkien’s novels have also become successful film franchises. Both series were popular in their own right beforehand, but this continued exposure may help to explain their current dominance.
Other titles on the list – such as Ian Fleming’s James Bond stories, George R. R. Martin’s Game of Thrones and Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials novels - probably also owe some of their popularity to successful film and television adaptations. It seems that film studios and television producers, like the readers who responded to the survey, are often drawn to trilogies and series.
Tolkien on 91热爆 Arts
-
Fantasy to reality: Lord of the Rings on the big screen
Alan Lee reveals his journey from book illustrator to concept design on Peter Jackson's movie trilogy.
-
Middle-earth in colour
How Tolkien created stunning illustrations of his fantasy universe.
-
The Lord of the Rings: Toughest ever quiz
Do you know your Gollum from your Gandalf?
Creating a ‘people's canon’
This research was inspired by the 91热爆’s list of The Novels That Shaped Our World. For Professors Sebastian Groes and Karina van Dalen-Oskam, who designed the study, it was interesting to compare the two lists.
“The 91热爆 list has been a great talking point,” Groes said, “but a selection of novels compiled by literary professionals is always going to be different to one chosen by the public. Our research shows us not just which books are considered to be important by those who make a living from literature, but which books people are reading because they enjoy them and think they are good.”
Van Dalen-Oskam was quick to point out that judgements made by the public were no less valid that those made by academics, literary agents and critics. “We can see from the responses that novels of all kinds are important to our participants, for all sorts of reasons. People are not just turning to adventure stories for escapism. They want titles that will help them think about the world in new ways.”
Your book recommendations
Groes and van Dalen-Oskam would like as many people as possible to take part in the ongoing research project. In particular, they are keen to see whether the patterns they have noticed in Adventure stories are replicated in other categories.
“Do readers still return to favourite childhood stories to understand politics, family or other worlds?”, Groes wondered, “or it simply the case that children’s authors tell the best Adventure stories?”
Take part in the project
-
...and get recommendations for books that are out of this world.
-
...and get recommendations for stories to inspire change.
-
See our full list of surveys...
...and get more personalised reading recommendations.
Novels That Shaped Our World
City of Bohane – Kevin Barry
Eye of the Needle – Ken Follett
For Whom the Bell Tolls – Ernest Hemingway
His Dark Materials Trilogy – Philip Pullman
Ivanhoe – Walter Scott
Mr Standfast – John Buchan
The Big Sleep – Raymond Chandler
The Hunger Games – Suzanne Collins
The Jack Aubrey Novels – Patrick O’Brian
The Lord of the Rings Trilogy – J.R.R. Tolkien
The panel also chose The Chronicles of Narnia and Game of Thrones, although these books appeared in different categories.
See the 91热爆’s full list of 100 Novels That Shaped Our World.
You might also like...
-
Spine-tingling tales: 10 of the best adventure stories ever told
More about the adventure novels chosen by our panel.
-
What can novels tell us about how men and women respond to a crisis?
Can the language that male and female authors use tell us about different leadership styles?
-
Get personalised reading recommendations
Help us complete the largest ever survey of English novels, and get recommendations for your next great read.
-
Making a protest: Ten political novels to challenge your views
Find out more about the ten novels about Politics, Power and Protest that our panel chose for The Novels That Shaped Our World.