Lent 1 - Jesus and the Father: United
Marking the first Sunday in Lent, with Father Dermot Preston SJ of St Aloysius’ RC Church in Glasgow and spirituality guide Mary O’Duffin.
Readings: John 12, Matthew 4: 1-11
Marking the first Sunday in Lent, with Father Dermot Preston SJ of St Aloysius’ RC Church in Glasgow, and spirituality guide, Mary O’Duffin.
During Lent, Radio 4 Worship programmes take inspiration from Jesuit spirituality – an ancient form of prayer and bible contemplation pioneered in the 16th Century by St Ignatius of Loyola and used widely today.
Fr Dermot explores the theme of Jesus’ Temptations, reflecting on the challenges to our own instincts and choices, and the ‘discernment of spirits’ in Ignatian spirituality.
Readings: John 12 / Matthew 4: 1-11
A link to accompanying online materials from the Ignatian Spirituality Centre can be found on the Sunday Worship web page.
Producer: Mo McCullough
Last on
Script
FR DERMOT PRESTON SJ
Good morning and welcome to Scotland for this service of music & prayer on this the First Sunday of Lent. We will use the ingenuity and resources that God has given us to weave a liturgy which will allow us to come together from up and down this land.
MUSIC: HYMN – O Worship the King
Choir of St Mary’s Episcopal Cathedral, Edinburgh directed by Dennis Townhill. Organ: Peter Backhouse. From CD: Famous Hymns of Praise, Label & Number Priory PRCD 376
FR DERMOT
Mary O’Duffin will be our spiritual guide this morning, steering us through the reflections and leading us into prayer.
MARY
During Lent, as a way of preparing for Easter, the 91ȱ is linking the Sunday worship programmes into a Christian retreat. Shaped by the spiritual tradition of St Ignatius of Loyola, it is an invitation to come to see God through the lens of Jesus Christ – spending time with him, learning from him, being challenged by him - to come to know the Father through him. You’ll find the information of the retreat on the Radio 4 Sunday Worship website.
MUSIC: Dignus est Agnus (Anon) / MacMillan
From CD: ‘MacMillan: Tenebrae Responsories & other choral works’
Label & Number: Hyperion CDA67970
FR DERMOT
The retreat’s suggested scripture passage for today actually catapults us into the frenzied atmosphere of Passover in the Jewish capital. According to John’s Gospel, just before the Last Supper, Jesus stood in the Temple in Jerusalem and cried aloud:
DAVID
‘Whoever believes in me believes not in me but in him who sent me. And whoever sees me sees him who sent me. I have come as light into the world, so that everyone who believes in me should not remain in the darkness. I do not judge anyone who hears my words and does not keep them, for I came not to judge the world, but to save the world. On the last day the word that I have spoken will serve as judge, for I have not spoken on my own, but the Father who sent me has himself given me a commandment about what to say and what to speak. And I know that his commandment is eternal life.’
FR DERMOT
In this slim passage Jesus neatly summarises his message to the world, and his unity with the Father. It is a razor-edged proclamation of certainty before his Passion and Death.
But I wonder, are we running a wee bit ahead of ourselves? Traditionally the liturgy for the first Sunday of Lent asks us to step back to the beginning of Jesus’ ministry and contemplate the Messiah who was starting out on his mission.
MUSIC: Do The Birds Worry? Composer: Cyrillus Kreek
Vox Clamantis directed by Jaan-Eik Tulve. From CD: Cyrillus Kreek: The Suspended Harp of Babel
Label & Number: ECM 2620
READER
“Then Jesus was led up by the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted by the devil.He fasted for forty days and forty nights, and afterwards he was hungry.”
FR DERMOT
Jesus is led by the Spirit up the steep climb from the Jordan valley, where he had been baptised, and is steered into the wilderness to the south of Jerusalem. Except for saying that Jesus was tempted, Mark’s Gospel leaves this incident tantalisingly unexplained.
But Luke and Matthew take the story further, drawing on the traditions of the early Church from whispers among the first companions of Jesus.
Let us allow Matthew to take up the story…
MICHAEL
The tempter came and said to Jesus, ‘If you are the Son of God, command these stones to become loaves of bread.’But Jesus answered, ‘It is written, “One does not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God.”’
FR DERMOT
Ironically Christians sometimes place an overemphasis on Jesus as being divine: he was God, but to be truly Christian we must recognise that Jesus was fully human. He was fasting and after 40 days and nights he was hungry. He thought about food; he imagined food; his stomach rumbled. He probably licked his lips when the Tempter mentioned… ‘b’. As one scholar puts it: the incarnate Jesus was given a mission, not immunity.
Is it wrong to feel hungry? No: it is part of being human – hunger prompts us to eat, and eating allows us to live. Part of the reality of our humanness is that we are awash with God-given desires and passions: some, like the hunger, are physical; some are intellectual; others emotional; others again, spiritual. If we deny that these passions exist, we are being dishonest; more ominously, we are leaving ourselves open to be driven blindfold into a dangerous storm. These passions can originate from our physical bodies or our emotional hearts or our instinctive souls – some are to be trusted, some are neutral; others are destructive – and they compete with each other to dominate.
MARY
If we ignore our desires or deny their existence, I am like the ship’s captain who ignores the storm that surrounds them and we just go down-below to sleep in the bunk. At best the ship will stray off-course, but more likely it will be run aground on the rocks or be broken by the wind and plunged into the depths of the sea. The skills of a good captain are to assess the multiple, competing powers which are buffeting the vessel and to use those currents and flows which will steer us safely, and minimise those that will damage and destroy. An inexperienced pilot who has the courage to stay at the helm will, at first, just see chaos; but with insight comes a growth of wisdom. Soon they will begin to sift the knowledge and distinguish the differences, and ultimately choose which tides to follow and which winds to resist.
FR DERMOT
“Domine, non secundum peccata nostra”, by James MacMillan: “O Lord, repay us not according to our sins.”
MUSIC – Domine, non secundum peccata nostra
Composer: James Macmillan, from CD ‘One Equal Music’. Elysian Singers conducted by Sam Laughton. Violin: Alexandra Caldron. Label & Number: Signum Classics SIGCD575
FR DERMOT
There are many different desires and levels of desire which I constantly balance; should I sleep or continue watching this film? Sleep is good; but the film is uplifting and inspiring. Which desire is better? There is not a set answer to that. I am choosing between apples and oranges and I cannot automatically say which is better. I need to try to make the best decision in the light of my knowledge, experience and instincts.
It might be useful at this point to note that some of us envisage evil as having a personality and which the Temptations narrative names ‘Satan’, ‘the Devil’ or ‘The Tempter’. Some of us though will see evil it as an unconscious power: like a virus-of-the-soul. Whatever our image, the force itself is deadly to the touch.
Most choices in our lives are actually not between good and evil, but between the good and the better. When a person is really trying to move in the direction of God, it is not easy for the Tempter to dangle evil before them; it is far more subtle for the devil to try to divert them to choose merely the good rather than the better. For the devil it is a small victory – but it is still a victory because it creates a slight division in the human heart – an uneasiness that we have not given our best.
So this temptation of Jesus is not with the simple act of eating bread – the Devil is trying to force Jesus to choose the good (nourish his body) instead of the better (to wait for God to provide, when the time is right). So the Temptation is to get Jesus to make a choice that would dislocate an integrity in the core of his heart.
MARY
Our world can present a bewildering array of choices.
Do these noisy demands of bodily desires drown out the quieter, deeply-rooted desires of honour, duty, faithfulness, loyalty or generosity?
Can I become still, and ponder honestly, deep in my heart, the times when I have compromised and settled for choices in my life which are second best?
Prayer:
Heavenly Father, You made us for yourself, O God, and our hearts are restless until they rest in you. As we ponder this truth, still the confusion of desires within. Let knowing Jesus guide us towards you. May your healing Spirit anoint our struggles, challenges, choices and loves.
MUSIC: Jacob's Dream / Orthodox Vespers: Proemial Psalm. Composer: Cyrillus Kreek
Vox Clamantis directed by Jaan-Eik Tulve. From CD: Cyrillus Kreek: The Suspended Harp of Babel
Label & Number: ECM 2620
MICHAEL
Then the devil took him to the holy city and placed him on the pinnacle of the temple,saying to him, ‘If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down; for it is written, “He will command his angels concerning you”, and “On their hands they will bear you up, so that you will not dash your foot against a stone.”’ Jesus said to him, ‘Again it is written, “Do not put the Lord your God to the test.”’
FR DERMOT
Some beaches around the British Isles have a very shallow gradient; and when the tides go out the water disappears into the far distance; when the tides comes in, they do so quickly. Here in Scotland the shallow gradients around the Argyle coastland and the Hebridean island of Tiree, for example, make them ideal for wind-surfing. Thus on such beaches around the British Isles, the sands at low-tide on a hot day stretch to the horizon and are flat, dry and desert-like. Les Dawson said that he once went for a walk along the sands of Southport beach and was mugged by Lawrence of Arabia.
I can’t remember exactly where the shallow beach was when the Preston family were on a family picnic: it could have been in Ireland. I was about 8 years old so my memories of time and place are vague but I remember there was some sort of argument and I was given an unreasonable telling-off. Being too close-by after you’ve had a telling-off is a stifling place, but I was also in a huff, so I started walking in the direction of the sea.
There were some shouts (which I ignored), but no pursuit so I walked steadily onwards. Even at that age, I knew I was pushing the edge of reasonableness. There was a danger, and it had been hinted at that we shouldn’t go too far away because it was risky as the tide might return. But I walked. I walked a long way. I walked so far that the family disappeared over the horizon behind me. Soon it was just me, the sand and the sky.
Now I am going to be a big disappointment to you: this story ends boringly. There was no racing tide to knock me off my feet; no quick-sands; no air-sea rescue helicopter; there was no close shave with a Great White Shark. After about 30 minutes I turned and walked back. I’d been gone about an hour. My parents were suitably narked and I got another telling off. End of Story.
But it didn’t quite end internally because I look back now and, 55 years later, and I can still touch the warm embers in the crucible of my feelings: of the rebellion, the challenge, but also of the uncertainty… That strange combination of the bravura “I’ll show them!” and the fearful “Will they let me die?”
Jesus wasn’t an 8-year old on an Irish beach, but I can resonate with the echo of the Tempter’s probing. The Devil was not quite tempting Jesus but more taunting him: “IF YOU ARE the Son of God…”
There will be part of Jesus which just wants to wipe the smirk off the Devil’s face – “I’ll show him!”; and yet also there will be a deeper existential question of “Will the Father protect?” and the sudden urge to test the relationship.
Once more, in this second temptation, at the profound level of the heart and soul, the Devil is trying to drive a wedge between the unity of the human heart of Jesus and the infinity of the Godhead. Can he provoke doubt in Jesus, cause a misstep and leave him feeling compromised?
MUSIC – Domine, non secundum peccata nostra
Composer: James Macmillan, from CD ‘One Equal Music’. Elysian Singers conducted by Sam Laughton. Violin: Alexandra Caldron. Label & Number: Signum Classics SIGCD575
MARY
When am I tempted to belittle or diminish others rather than show sympathy and understanding?
Has my own woundedness ever driven me to wound others in word or deed?
Using my personal gifts, do I foster anger or resentment in others rather than encouragement and support?
Do I use social media as a means of gaining the “upper hand” or as a means of sharing truth, light and friendship?
Am I ever boastful or smug in order to undermine another’s sense of worth?
Do I take secret delight in harming another through gossip?
FR DERMOT
As the saints would counsel: never be frightened or panicked by the prompting of a spirit. If that spirit is of God it will be happy to be scrutinised and discerned; whereas the devil hides in half-shadow trying to bend the light away and hurry things along, instilling the heart with a shuffling fear.
It is a strange Greek word: “Pterygion”. It is only used twice in the New Testament: in the Temptations narratives of Luke and Matthew. The word is often translated as the ‘pinnacle’ of the Temple. But it literally means ‘little wing’/winglet of the Temple. Pterodactyl is the same root – a winged dinosaur. Pterygion. Matthew (who knows his scripture intimately) is likely ghosting the rabbinic understanding of the Jerusalem Temple being a symbol of the divine eagle spreading its protective wings over the people of Israel.
MUSIC: On Eagles’ Wings
Composer: Alexander L’Estrange. From CD ‘On Eagles’ Wings’. Label & Number: Signum Classics SIGCD454
MARY
From ‘God’s Grandeur’, by Gerard Manley Hopkins.
“…And for all this, nature is never spent;
There lives the dearest freshness deep down things;
And though the last lights off the black West went
Oh, morning, at the brown brink eastward, springs —
Because the Holy Ghost over the bent
World broods with warm breast and with ah! bright wings.”
FR DERMOT
In 1987 Stephen King wrote a novel set in a small town called Castle Rock.
One day a mysterious shop opens in the centre of the town. The shop is called ‘Needful Things’. No-one locally knew anything about it, just one morning it was there. People are curious and one by one they engineer to pass by to look in the window, and some venture in.
The proprietor, tall, elegant Leland Gaunt, is both charming and commanding. As the story of the novel unfolds, so do the stories of the people of the town. Each of them has a background, each has a history; each has hopes & fears; they wrestle with failure, they strive to improve. Leland Gaunt understands each of them intimately and with each tinkle of the silver bell as the shop-door opens, they might come in hesitantly, but when they do they always find what they want…
How do I hear the beguiling sales-pitch of Leland Gaunt?
MUSIC: Do The Birds Worry? Composer: Cyrillus Kreek
Vox Clamantis directed by Jaan-Eik Tulve. From CD: Cyrillus Kreek: The Suspended Harp of Babel
Label & Number: ECM 2620
DAVID
“The lost toy from childhood… the rare baseball card… the fishing rod… the
medallion that relieves the pain… – they are all here! But on finding it, people
say to me: Ah! I can’t pay those big city prices! Surely I will never be
able to afford such a wonderful thing??
The price? I answer; It is not
really about money… a few dollars perhaps, but I have a little task that I
would ask of you… A prank - a mere trifle! What is it in comparison with the
precious gift you have found and which could be yours…?”
READER
Again, the devil took Jesus to a very high mountain and showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their splendour;and he said to him, ‘All these I will give you, if you will fall down and worship me.’Jesus said to him, ‘Away with you, Satan! for it is written, “Worship the Lord your God,and serve only him.”’
DERMOT
From the Jordan to the wilderness to the pinnacle of the temple and now to this impossibly high mountain, the stakes of the poker-game rise higher with the altitude. Yet, despite the wondrous landscape around them, it is the Devil who is front and centre. He has dropped the false innocence of the first Temptation, and the fey sardonic tone of the second Temptation, for now he has a weighty offer for Jesus that can stand on its own merits.
Everyone has desires and needs: everyone has their price – what is the price of Jesus? It is all very well being idealistic, but he needs to be practical. Control over the whole world, here and now? A world he is meant to redeem!?
This is the deal which each of us is likely to be faced with at some point in our lives. Not quite everything, but almost everything. But to achieve it we will need to compromise with something small, but something deeply rooted within our souls.
As in the parable of the village of Castle Rock, where the cumulated pranks cause real damage, Leland Gaunt is eventually unmasked as the Devil himself and it becomes clear that he has found the price of each person. The small compromises are spiralling their community into division and disintegration.
J. Robert Oppenheimer is one of the great scientists of the 20th Century. I first came across his work in Quantum Mechanics when I studied Chemistry at University.
But what makes Oppenheimer’s name so well-known was that he became the lead scientist on the US development of the nuclear bomb during the Second World War. Oppenheimer was offered the job of co-ordinating the stellar cast of world-renowned scientists to take the theory of nuclear science and to turn it into the reality of a droppable bomb in just three years. He took the job; they accomplished the task.
But as the project approached completion, Oppenheimer began to realise that his power was ebbing away to the politicians and the military and he was becoming merely advisory; and when the bomb-test in New Mexico was successful, Oppenheimer (a secular Jew with an interest in Hinduism) spontaneously remembered a chilling phrase from the Bhagavad Gita: “I am become death, the destroyer of worlds.”
In the years that followed, Oppenheimer was haunted by his involvement with the tens of thousands of deaths from Hiroshima and Nagasaki. He looked back and, although he recognised there had been a passionately good desire to deter the ambition of the Axis forces, who were so close to the same expertise, and to stop the slaughter of the war quickly, he saw that, crucially, the scientists at the cutting-edge had been intellectually tempted. Using a laser-like phrase, Oppenheimer said that he, and the other scientists, found the challenge ‘technically sweet’. It was this hypnotic attachment to the intellectual problem which had gently but profoundly unbalanced their task: “You go ahead and do it,” he said, ”and you argue about what to do about it only after you have had your technical success.” But by then it was too late.
In a lecture to MIT in 1947, Oppenheimer summarises this compromise in one of the most poignant sentences in the history of science:
DAVID
“In some sort of crude sense which no vulgarity, no humour, no overstatement can quite extinguish, the physicists have known sin; and this is a knowledge which they cannot lose.”
MUSIC – Domine, non secundum peccata nostra
Composer: James Macmillan, from CD ‘One Equal Music’. Elysian Singers conducted by Sam Laughton. Violin: Alexandra Caldron. Label & Number: Signum Classics SIGCD575
MARY
Can I recall a time when, against the prompting of my best self, I compromised something deep within?
Perhaps there was a niggle or a doubt that I chose to ignore?
Did a vague insight grow into certainty of a misguided choice?
Or perhaps it was in viewing the damage and hurt of that compromise, that I recognised the consequences of that choice?
FR DERMOT
In his book “The Spiritual Exercises”, St Ignatius of Loyola names evil as “the enemy of our human nature”. He would emphasise how it is folly for us to think that we can negotiate with the forces of darkness, no matter how reasonable or enticing an offer it might appear to be.
In the Temptations narrative, notice how Jesus never negotiates with the Devil – there is no banter or even argument – as he will have later, for example, with the Pharisees. The Gospel is clear that the marauding entity which is Evil is alien to our being and will always attempt to inflict colossal damage on the human heart.
MARY
God of the Heart,
You show us that temptation alone is not sin.
In Jesus you show us the power of a human heart united to you.
Mend our broken wills and hearts,
That through Jesus, we may bring peace and unity to others.
MUSIC: HYMN – O God, you search me and you know me (Bernadette Farrell)
From CD: Favourite Catholic Hymns. Choirs of the Dioceses of Leeds
Label & Number: Herald HAVPCD 397
MICHAEL
“Then the devil left him, and suddenly angels came and waited on him.”
FR DERMOT
The Devil tempted Jesus to provoke the appearance of angels by throwing himself down from the winglet of the Temple, but he didn’t – and the angels came in God’s Good Time. Matthew uses the word ‘پDzԴdzܲ’… ‘ministering to him’.
As you might expect the battle between Jesus and the Devil is being played out against the backdrop of the Old Testament. The Devil – note he can quote Scripture like the best of us! - cites the beautiful Psalm 91 about God’s care for his creatures. But Jesus’ three quotations spring from just three chapters of the Book of Deuteronomy where Moses reminds the People of Israel that they were tempted in the wilderness and they failed. Jesus was tempted in the wilderness and succeeded. As Moses climbed Mt Nebo and could only gaze into the Promised Land, Jesus (who in Matthew’s eyes is the ‘New Moses’) goes up the highest mountain and will now lead the People of God into Eternal Life.
MARY
God of Promises
The symmetry of your salvation catches our breath.
Patiently you journey with us through history.
And you do not despise this life, this biography, this year of 2021.
The Promise of your Son, Jesus, patiently waits for us.
Help us to trust your word.
FR DERMOT AND MARY: Lord’s Prayer
FR DERMOT
When Luke completes his telling of the Temptations story, he adds a phrase not found in Matthew:
MICHAEL
“When the devil had finished all this tempting,he left himuntil an opportune time.”
FR DERMOT
“An opportune time.” The Greek word is ‘Kairos’… Often seen as an opportune time for God and God’s people, but Luke is wanting to make clear that the ending of the Temptations does not mean the disappearance of the Tempter - he will return when the time is right.
MUSIC: Dignus est Agnus (Anon) / MacMillan
From CD: ‘MacMillan: Tenebrae Responsories & other choral works’
Label & Number: Hyperion CDA67970
FR DERMOT
In John’s Gospel we will catch a reflection of him when he incites the crowd to push to make Jesus King after he fed the five thousand with bread. We will glimpse him also nudging Peter to urge Jesus to tone down the predictions of the Passion he was to suffer – “Get behind me Satan!” Jesus yells “What does it profit a man to gain the whole world and to lose his very soul?!” A deal Jesus himself had been offered.
But we also see in the ministry of Jesus times when he shares the wisdom of his experience discerning the spirits of good and evil. Lord, how can we tell the difference between a true prophet and a false prophet? “You can tell them by their fruits….Every good tree bears good fruit, but the bad tree bears bad fruit.” Should we root out evil like weeds? “No, lest while you gather up the tares you also uproot the wheat with them.Let both grow together until the harvest.”
MARY
God of growing things
Scatter your Word in our world and in our hearts.
Do not break the bent reed nor judge the tiniest seed.
You wish that all be saved - give time for hearts to burn with divine love.
Through Jesus, the Christ, let us see the face of the Father and the Power of the Spirit.
Amen
FR DERMOT
So, let us leave Jesus now, gazing across a landscape from the high mountain, being ministered to by angels as he ponders his next step. And let us ask the blessing of the Spirit of Christ as we continue to walk on our pilgrim way. We ask that Spirit to heal our brokenness, to give strength & courage to our fight and to knit together the integrity which our hearts desire. Amen.
MUSIC: HYMN –
Praise to the holiest in the height
From CD: Ultimate Hymns Volume 4 Label & Number: Authentic Media 8204672
Broadcast
- Sun 21 Feb 2021 08:1091ȱ Radio 4