91热爆

bbc.co.uk Navigation

Absence of nostalgia

  • Nick
  • 21 Sep 06, 03:13 PM

Like a stick of Brighton rock Ming Campbell's speech (watch it in full here) had one word running though it - the word was substance.

He wanted, of course, to draw a contrast with the spin which he alleges David Cameron has copied from Tony Blair. He wanted too to signal to his own party that the days when they could rely on a likeable leader and a handful of populist symbolic policies were over.

Campbell knows that much of his party's current appeal is time-limited. The war in Iraq will be long gone by the time of the next election - along, of course, with Messrs Blair and Bush. Hence the importance the Lib Dem leader attaches to its decision this week to adopt green taxes as as an answer to what Ming Campbell calls the greatest moral and practical challenge we face - climate change.

Just as significant for him was the absence of nostalgia for the man he replaced - Charles Kennedy. There was not a mention of him in today's speech. The party has moved on - no mean achievement given where they were a few months ago. Now, the rather bigger task begins of selling their new leader and new policies to the public.

An age old question

  • Nick
  • 21 Sep 06, 12:26 PM

We are the party of substance. That's the message Ming Campbell wants to go out from Brighton today. It's a message that's supposed to work on many levels.

Sir Menzies Campbell at his party's conferenceTo his activists he's saying, "we are not a party of symbolism".
Translation - Charles Kennedy was all symbols and no gong. Let's consign populist gestures and woolly thinking to the past along with him.

To the country he's saying, "we are not a party of spin".
Translation - I may not be as photogenic as David Cameron but at least you know what I think.

To the media he's saying, "political debate in this country is in danger of losing sight of what matters".
Translation - do stop going on about how old I am.

Before you shout "hear hear" just dwell for a moment on the fact that his speech is to be preceded by a slide show (they couldn't afford a video) showing Ming the world-class athlete, Ming the fighter pilot (actually, he was only a passenger in the jet in the photo) and Ming the campaigner alongside Nelson Mandela.

Menzies Campbell, pictured with some of the party's prospective parliamentary candidates on the seafront at BrightonMing began the week, you may recall, with a photo opportunity with "Campbell's crackers" (er, women MPs to you and me). Later he declared that he knew the Arctic Monkeys had sold more records than the Beatles (which they haven't).

The Lib Dems are in danger of looking just a little too anxious about their new leader's image. They winced at of Ming in a wheelchair wrapped in a car rug declaring, "go back to your constituencies and prepare for death". They fear that all anyone knows about him is his age.

They want, quite understandably, people to know that their man started life in a Glasgow tenement and made a success in sport and the law before turning to politics. They know that they've traded a well-known and well-liked leader for one many can't even name.

Perhaps though they should heed their leader's speech. Ming's predecessors won the public's attention by taking stands on issues of substance. Ashdown did it on the plight of Hong Kong Chinese and Bosnia. The fact that he had been in the counted, I suspect, for little. Kennedy did it on Iraq. The fact that he started life in a Highland croft scarcely mattered.

Voters do want to know about the lives and the backgrounds of their leaders. We, in the media, have a voracious appetite for it but Campbell is right - he'll be judged by substance not stills of his past life.

PS: They've just played that slide show and the conference laughed at the "Top Gun" image of Ming the fighter (pilot) passenger.

The 91热爆 is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

91热爆.co.uk