The turnout in this year's general election was at a record low, with forty
percent of voters not bothering to vote at all. But if turnout had been
higher, the results of a poll for the Today programme suggest that it could
have led to an even worse result for the Conservatives.
The Result of the 2001 General Election |
One thousand and
eight non-voters were asked which party they would have been most likely to
support had they voted; fifty three percent said Labour, and nineteen
percent said the Tories. When regional variations in swing and turnout are
taken into account, that could have affected Tory victories in around two
dozen seats.
Many Conservatives have said that Labour's record in government
has turned voters off politics; but central office strategists will be
concerned that even those who couldn't be bothered to vote would still
choose Labour rather than the conservatives.
The poll for the Today programme was carried out by the Conservatives' own
pollsters, ICM. Just over a thousand non voters from around the country were
asked: "If you had actually gone to vote in the General Election, which
party do you think you would have voted for?" 53% said they'd have backed
the Labour party. 19% said they'd have voted Tory. Martin Boon is associate
director of ICM. He says this shows the Conservatives are at rock bottom.
"This is terrible for the Conservative Party," he said. "It shows that in
spite of what they may hope, there is no resevoir of untapped support out
there."
Of course, asking people how they'd vote two months after the general
election and when they know the result is likely to skew answers in favour
of the winner - in this case Labour. So perhaps the Tories can take heart in
that. But the poll suggests that their support is far lower among non
voters, so if turnout was increased, the Tories could expect to actually
LOSE seats rather than win them.
"We don't like to make seat projections because of the variations in
turnout," said Martin Boon. "Then there's the fact that these staistics
can't tell the whole story: if more non voters did turn out it would have a
disproportionate effect on Labour areas."
Nevertheless, in his professional opinion he estimates that the Tories could
have been on course to lose anything from 20-40 seats had turnout been
higher on June 7th. That would have left Labour with an overall majority of
215. Since 1832 only one party has won a bigger majority: the Conservatives
won by 223 seats in 1924.
The Projected Result of the 2001 General Election including non-voters voting intentions |
But within the Conservative Party this is not the received wisdom. Bob Spink
is one of the few Conservatives to have won back a seat from the Labour
party in the last general election. He has a wafer thin majority (just 985
votes) in Castle Point in Essex and our poll indicates that could well have
been jeopardised if more non voters turned out.
Mr Spink blames the low
turnout in the general election on the public's increasing mistrust of the
government, and particularly the Prime Minister. He is also worried there
may be a media agenda at work. "This is nothing but Today programme bias
towards the Conservative Party," he says.
The Tories are consoling themselves by saying that the results of 2001 were
a complete freak - and that even though many people did not turn out to
vote, their support is there for the taking if the party gets its policies
right.
Speaking on the Today programme recently Tory leadership contender
Ken Clarke said all the major parties failed to excite the electorate at the
General Election. "None of the the political parties had aroused their
enthusiasm," he told James Naughtie. "None of the political parties had
persuaded them that they really knew how to address the big problems
concerning the public. That makes the next election wide open."
His opponent, meanwhile, believes the Conservatives must challenge the what
he sees as the cynicism of the Labour Government. In the speech announcing
his candidacy in the leadership race Iain Duncan-Smith said: "Whilst the
election defeat was a bitter blow to the Conservatives, the low turnout is
also a signal of the despair people feel about the political process under
Mr Blair."
But the Today/ICM poll suggests it might not be that easy. It indicates that
the majority of non voters have already made up their minds, and they don't
like the Conservatives. That leaves the party with an tough battle to win
back the votes of the electorate.