91Èȱ¬

Explore the 91Èȱ¬
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

24 September 2014
Press Office
Search the 91Èȱ¬ and Web
Search 91Èȱ¬ Press Office

91Èȱ¬ 91Èȱ¬page

Contact Us

Benoit Witchalls speaking on Crimewatch

Press Releases

Crimewatch: transcript of interview with Benoit Witchalls


Category: TV Factual

Date: 18.05.2005
Printable version


FIONA BRUCE: Let's talk about Abigail to begin with. How's she doing?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Yeah, she's still a remarkable character so I think I've had a crash course in spinal injury - and you just can't tell anything for the first month, so it's a case of wait and see really. But she's still got her smile which is very comforting to see, yeah.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: I mean at the moment she's paralysed from the neck down isn't she. Is that something for the future now?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: You just can't tell at this stage; obviously she's had quite a lot of clinical diagnosis done, but it's mostly different opinions but nothing definitive. So, yeah, just have to wait for the month. They say it will take about normally about four weeks before you can get more of a feel based on her condition, to get a feel for how she will improve.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: And at the moment she can't speak, can she?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: At the moment she has this tracheotomy in her throat. There are ways of being able to speak with a valve, and I'll probably get all the medical jargon wrong, but they can release her cuff back - and so for about half an hour a day she's able to speak which is great, but she can only speak as she breathes in so we have a bit of a laugh at how funny it sounds - but yeah.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: Well it's something you can have a laugh about then.

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Yeah and, and she really looks forward to being able to speak for, you know, half an hour.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: How are you coping?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Well it's just based on her condition three weeks ago, what I was told then. If I base it on that then it's just, we just feel very lucky and very blessed because she's fully present as herself, and that's just great to see and you know and it's a great joy, you can see her face when she sees Joseph, and Joseph's coping amazingly and I would say he's the real kind of joy in, in the family I suppose, and obviously we, we want to try and keep his life as stable and, and normal as possible for him, not to upset him too much.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: And are you going to see her every day, do you take Joseph in every day?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: We get Joseph in there every day, try to balance it out with his, meals and naps and things and but yes he's been able to see her every day so far.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: How did you hear about what had happened?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: I was at work and I got a phone call from my mum. It was a friend of hers who first found Abigail, and in fact Abigail communicated to her because she saw that Joseph was quite upset obviously, and we're quite close to, to our house where my mum lives in Barton, that she wanted Joseph to kind of not be upset anymore, and so asked for her to come - I think before the ambulance was called, actually - to make sure that he was comforted, yeah.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: And so you were told what by, by your friend?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: So I was told by my mum, she phoned and she'd, luckily probably, she just said that Abigail had had an accident and she was taken to Epsom Hospital, so I at the time obviously didn't realise how serious it was so I just headed straight there.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: And there must have been times where you thought she wasn't going to make it?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Well, yeah you know, when you know somebody as being so fit and active and you know really enjoyed the outdoor life and trying to get everywhere kind of walking and cycling as much as we could - yeah, it's obviously not something I've had to think about. But that first evening on Wednesday the twentieth - it was just very difficult for any doctors to come up with anything definitive.

Ìý

What they knew was that she had a wound at the back of her neck, but how serious it was they didn't know - but obviously the opinions ranged from absolutely critical to 'Well she may well be stable, not at the moment but, you know, quite soon.'

Ìý

And that's when they were deciding whether she needed to have, or that she did need to have an MRI scan and I think that the nearest place they could do that was at the Atkinson Morley in Saint George's, so there was concern about moving her from Epsom because she was still quite critical.

Ìý

But luckily - from what we can tell - the move went okay. That was about probably six or seven hours after, after the attacks.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: I mean we've read things in the paper, you know, about Abigail communicating through blinking and this kind of thing - it's hard for anyone to imagine what that must be like and, and the upheaval in your lives. How are you all coping with that?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: I suppose like I said it's very much day by day, it's trying to arrange who's going to be with Abi when.

Ìý

Obviously with Joseph as well, we can only plan that day by day really, but I think just seeing her with such a strong character and that she's so happy that Joseph is safe and well.

Ìý

That gives us great comfort obviously, and you know it's day by day and so you don't really have time to think about how it used to be, I suppose. It's very much my expectation is that I'm going to go in and I'll be able to talk to Abigail about my day and how it's been going with her. And between trying to understand our son - he has quite a basic vocabulary - and Abigail, who's trying to lip read things, we're getting much better. The blinking - now I think we must have got a lot better at lip reading because we haven't had to do the blinking thing for a couple days.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: So that's good progress?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: I think it probably as a team yes, she's been able to articulate it better and we've been able to pick it up easier.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: What was your kind of routine like, your life with Abi like before all this happened?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Routine was a word we always thought we'd wouldn't use to reflect our lives, you know both being kind of quite young and ahead of our peers in getting married and having children, but that is to say we did and so Abi would normally do something with Joseph every day and I would either be at work or I'd be working from home; and she'd go to different toddler groups in the week and Wednesdays is Messy Monkeys, and I always used to look forward to them coming home or me coming home because Joseph would normally have created some masterpiece, which has littered our walls.

Ìý

In fact I haven't seen what he created that Wednesday. I guess the Police have got it, but look forward to seeing it. But the week before, it was some butterfly or something like that, but she'd go every other week normally.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: And she was a very active person? You both lived very active lives by the sounds of it before this happened?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Yes we've got to have active lives again you know, but we did, we often go walking, cycling, and our holidays were normally based around outdoor activities, yes.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: What are your feelings towards the person who did this to Abi?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: My personal feelings are that I, we haven't, haven't really thought about it much, you know life is just a lottery and this could have so easily happened as it does to so many people through a car accident or through, you know, some sort of illness.

Ìý

It's just that something which has happened to us - but to be honest I haven't thought much about the attacker. Obviously, you know, whoever did it needs help and it would absolutely tragic if this was to happen again to somebody.

Ìý

So you know maybe the reason I'm here talking to you is so that, you know, this, this person can be found and something can be done to help them some way. I mean we haven't had any feelings of, you know, kind of anger - it's just a case of, you know, helping out this person really to.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: I mean some people will find that remarkable - you know, you say you haven't got feelings of anger towards this person who.

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Well, maybe it will come - I don't know. But at the moment it's just a case of it's obviously very sad, someone that, that's probably suffered in their lives and we've just got to see what we can as a society do to help them.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: And Abi feels the same, does she?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Yes, I think so. We haven't really spoken about the attack other than the Police interviews, but she didn't seem to be too traumatised by it. I suppose, obviously, obviously she has been thinking - you know, why, why did this happen? Why am I suffering like this? But she certainly hasn't communicated to me, "Who is this person that did this to me? 'Cos I really want to strangle their neck, or whatever."

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: I mean, she would be forgiven for saying that in a lot of people's eyes, this person held a knife to your son's throat, has had this terrible effect on your wife - and yet you're talking about him in a very compassionate and very forgiving way.

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Well yes, thank God that our son's well. That was the reason her first word that she blinked was "happy", because she was so relieved that he had come out of it unscathed physically, yes.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: What would you say to people who will be listening to you now and who might know something, or indeed the attacker himself, but haven't come forward yet?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Like I said, it will be absolutely tragic if this person did this to somebody else, you know, it would just be real tragedy, so it's a case of let's just make sure that, you know, we can find him.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: It's a him - but it's a man with distinctive earrings, we know that much.

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: So make sure that we find him so that we can give him the support that he needs.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: I mean people will find it incredible that you're saying, "Let's find him so we can give him the support he needs." You know he very nearly killed Abigail, it's a miracle he didn't.

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Yes, absolutely.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: And he held a knife to Joseph's throat but you want to give him support not punishment? Or a bit of both?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: No, I mean I certainly wouldn't want to pass any judgement.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: I think it's remarkable that you, for many people - in a good way, obviously - it is remarkable that you can talk in such a forgiving and tolerant way about someone who has done something so terrible to your family. I mean what, what, how are you able to do that?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Well I suppose that the suffering that we're going through - yeah it is, it is really hard, and I think maybe had Abigail died or were she to have suffered quite severe brain damage, maybe I'd be spending a lot more time. Not having her, because we work very much as a team - just to talk about our lives and stuff - that would have been a massive loss to me.

Ìý

But, but Abi is still there, she's still present, and that is just a tremendous relief and we feel very blessed and lucky that she is, and yes we're going suffer obviously as, as a family.

Ìý

It may well be that she's going to be paralysed from the neck down for life but, you know, people live wonderful lives paralysed from the neck down. Our expectations have had to change drastically in the last three weeks, but that's not to say that we're not still going to live peaceful lives, with a family.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: Let me ask you two more questions if I may - which is, I want to come back to what would you say to people who might know something. You know, there's been so much public attention, I think public sympathy, about this case and what's happened to Abigail, and of course you know what Joseph has been through. A lot of people want to know how Joseph's coping, if he's suffering sort of nightmares or been damaged by this or is he doing okay?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: I'm no psychologist but you know he's still making a fuss about the same old things and he's still very much himself as I knew him a month ago. And he's sleeping really well - he's eating as well as you can expect for a toddler, and he's just, he seems to be an amazingly stable little boy even though he's obviously had to shuffle around quite a bit between families and I haven't been around every evening to put him to bed, or to be with him. He's done, he's doing amazingly, yeah.

Ìý

FIONA BRUCE: What would you say to people who are listening to you now who might know something, maybe even the attacker himself, who haven't yet come forward with information?

Ìý

MR WITCHALLS: Well, no doubt the Police will say, 'You know, don't approach him and call this number', and I suppose I'd say the same thing, just so that this doesn't really happen again through this guy.

Ìý

Just any slightest suspicion that they may have had, it's important to just report that even if you think it's not going to be useful or relevant. That's what I've been told by the Police, you know any bit of information that you can think of - just, just tell the right people and, and let them decide whether or not it's important.

Ìý

But Abi has quite a clear image in her, in her mind of the attacker, and she has quite a clear image of the car he was driving as well, so you know hopefully that will jog people's memories and enable him to be, to be found and then we'll see.

Ìý


PRESS RELEASES BY DATE :



PRESS RELEASES BY:

FOLLOW

Category: TV Factual

Date: 18.05.2005
Printable version

top^


The 91Èȱ¬ is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



About the 91Èȱ¬ | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy
Ìý