91Èȱ¬

91Èȱ¬ BLOGS - The Devenport Diaries

Archives for January 2011

Baron Enright

Mark Devenport | 12:20 UK time, Monday, 31 January 2011

Comments

What with all the attention on Gerry Adams' Stewardship of Northstead (the Sinn Fein Baron joked with me last week that I wasn't showing him sufficient deference), this blog is in danger of losing sight of another unexpected elevation to the ranks of the British aristocracy.

Downpatrick Green councillor Cadogan Enright has been appointed to a UK wide panel which will select eight potential Green Lords. The Greens are opposed to an unelected Upper House, but pending its reform are seeking places in the Lords in proportion to their vote. Councillor Enright hopes "Northern Ireland will potentially get its first Green Lord as a result of this process".

Any nominations? Viscount Brian Wilson, maybe, or Archduke John Gilliland (not a Green as such but a former Euro candidate with a background in renewable energy) or even Baron Enright himself?

The Greens may be glad of a local voice, as the latest Irish polls suggest they face annihilation in the Dail, whilst Steven Agnew will face an uphill struggle to retain the party's single Stormont seat.

But what happens if a Green "takes the ermine"? Do they have an option to save the stoat by insisting on artificial fur?

Aer Adams

Mark Devenport | 09:02 UK time, Friday, 28 January 2011

Comments

Back in the 1970s Campari had a TV ad in which an upper class gent asked the beautiful girl beside him "Did you really fly here from heaven?" to which Lorraine Chase replied "Nah, Luton Airport".

Gerry Adams doesn't need to turn to Easyjet or Ryan Air to help him make the short trip from West Belfast to County Louth. But on the face of it, this north south commuter is dabbling in the travel business.

I was down in Drogheda yesterday filming some material for a report on the Irish election and Sinn Fein had just opened up a new campaign office in the town's main street (this is in addition to their regular constituency office). The Sinn Fein President is ahead of the pack with his leaflets all printed, but the sign above the office continues to read "Budget Travel" whilst another sign proclaims Gerry's new base to be a recognised "Aer Lingus agent".

I was going to call the new office "Gerryjet" but out of deference to the second sign I suppose I should opt for "Aer Adams". Either way Sinn Fein will hope that, notwithstanding the recent criticism of Mr Adams' grasp of economics and the details of the Irish tax and benefits system, their President is cleared for take off.

The Leaving of Westminster

Mark Devenport | 12:10 UK time, Tuesday, 25 January 2011

Comments

After twenty seven years of a dysfunctional relationship with the Westminster authorities, it's now clear that Gerry Adams finds, like Neil Sedaka, that "breaking up is hard to do". The Speaker's office insists that, so far as they are concerned, the Sinn Fein President remains West Belfast MP, not withstanding his letter of resignation. My previous assumption that election to the Dail would disbar Mr Adams from Westminster was wrong, as Newsnight's Michael Crick has pointed out on his blog that the Disqualifications Act of 2000 enables the Sinn Fein President to be a member of both houses.

It's not the leaving of Westminster that will grieve Gerry Adams - Irish republicans will not feel any inclination to help the British authorities out with their procedural conundrum. But whilst this matter appears arcane, it does have an impact on the real world in as much as it puts in doubt when, or whether, there will be a by-election in West Belfast.

The parliamentary website Again for reasons of Irish republican tradition, there is now way Gerry Adams will consider this - so, if the failure to hold a by-election becomes a running sore, is it possible that the Chancellor could appoint Mr Adams to "an ofice pf profit under the crown" without consulting him? Alternatively could Westminster take the view that, given the West Belfast MP's long term abstentionism, there's no hurry to fill his seat?

George Spurns Danny

Mark Devenport | 16:48 UK time, Monday, 24 January 2011

Comments

Well, it was fun while it lasted. Danny Morrison says he half jokingly suggested George Galloway as a potential successor to Gerry Adams in West Belfast last week. Today the former Respect MP responded in a column in the Scottish Daily Record insisting that So no socialist Enoch Powell then...

P.S. Mr Galloway says the 91Èȱ¬ didn't try to contact him, but my colleague Martina Purdy did e-mail his official website seeking a comment before she ran the Danny Morrison suggestion. She got a reply the next day saying Mr Galloway was on his way to the USA.

Superb Style

Mark Devenport | 15:25 UK time, Monday, 24 January 2011

Comments

So the Stormont Finance department has authorised the replacement of ten ministerial cars at a cost of just under £200,000. A proposal that some of the politicians should consider vehicle sharing didn't get very far. The fleet consists of Skoda Superbs.

Personally I'd be more than happy to drive around in one, although someone pointed out to me that Jeremy Clarkson reckons and that "telling people you have one marks you out as someone with no style at all".

Move over Gerry?

Mark Devenport | 15:11 UK time, Monday, 24 January 2011

Comments

Pearse Doherty was being cross questioned on RTE radio today about how Sinn Fein could implement cuts in Northern Ireland whilst opposing them in the Republic (the same charge of double standards which was levelled at the party by the eirigi General Secretary Breandán Mac Cionnaith). The Donegal TD defended Sinn Fein by pointing out that the Stormont Executive can't raise taxes, whilst the Irish government can.

The pundits on the programme felt Pearse Doherty held his own against Pat Rabbitte and would be "a thorn in Labour's side" as the campaign got underway. Then Noel Whelan ( a former Fianna Fail candidate and author of the Tallyman's campaign handbook) chipped in with a bit of advice for Sinn Fein: "keep Gerry Adams in Dundalk".

Danny smitten by Gorgeous George

Mark Devenport | 18:05 UK time, Friday, 21 January 2011

Comments

This morning, put on the spot about who might take Gerry Adams' seat in West Belfast, I suggested a few names - Alex Maskey to shift over from South Belfast, Caitriona Ruane to return to her West Belfast festival domain, or Bobby Storey to complete his conversion from physical force republicanism to the electoral side of the movement. I omitted Seanna Walsh, the former IRA prisoner who read out its order to decommission arms in 2005, but certaibly should have included him.

But one name I must admit I wouldn't have thought of in a month of Sundays was that of the former Respect MP, George Galloway. Famous for his opposition to the Iraq war, his admiration for Saddam Hussein's "indefatigability", taking on the US Congress head to head and impersonating a cat lapping up milk on Big Brother, Mr Galloway's name didn't immediately spring to my mind - but it did to Sinn Fein's former publicity director Danny Morrison.

Danny has written a column for Monday's Andersonstown News arguing that if the people of West Belfast returned George to Westminster he would be an "incendiary presence" and "a voice for the oppressed of this earth. It would be us 'invading' them, a major reversal of colonialism, a statement of our internationalism."

Sinn Fein's initial response is that Mr Galloway isn't a party member so wouldn't qualify to participate in their selection convention. So maybe George shouldn't get his hopes up.

When the West Belfast by-election might be held remains far from clear. Gerry Adams has written to the Speaker John Bercow to say he's stepping down. But he won't abide by the British tradition of MPs being unable to resign unless they apply for the "Chiltern hundreds".

On the face of it this presents a dillemma for the Speaker's office - if an outgoing MP is determined to flout parliamentary tradition, you would presume the Westminster authorities would try to find a way to ensure the electorate get a chance to choose a successor. However when I contacted the Speaker's office today all I got was a restatement of the "Chiltern hundreds" tradition as set out in the Commons bible Erskine May. This didn't answer the question, and the Speaker's office wouldn't add anything to it. Perhaps Mr Bercow will wait to see if the Sinn Fein President secures election to the Dail and then rule that he has disbarred himself from being an MP. Or maybe if he hears George Galloway is in the running, the Speaker might pretend the letter from Gerry Adams got lost in the post.

Political Road Movies

Mark Devenport | 17:08 UK time, Thursday, 20 January 2011

Comments

With resignations and reshuffles the order of the day in Dublin, the Irish Times' Miriam Lord gave some sage advice to aspiring TDs this morning, warning them that if Brian Cowen "dangles the keys of a Mercedes Benz under your nose, do not give in to base political impulse."

But, like Mr Toad in the Wind In The Willows, the lure of the automobile is too much for some politicians. Tomorrow Brian Cowen will hit the road for a high level meeting with his Stormont counterparts. As one wag put it "the Irish government were due to arrive in a coach, but now they might all fit into a mini".

Whilst the southerners head north, the easterners are driving west. Officials from Stormont are due to be at the University of Ulster's Magee campus tomorrow to meet voluntary and community groups from west of the Bann and to pass on practical tips about how they can get more involved with Stormont committee inquiries. MLAs from various western constituencies will be in attendance for a question and answer session.

Teamwork: SDLP style

Mark Devenport | 09:41 UK time, Thursday, 20 January 2011

Comments

The SDLP has confirmed that their long standing Fermanagh representative Tommy Gallagher will stand again in May's assembly election. The former UTV presenter Fearghal McKinney, who represented the party in the Westminster election, will take on a campaigning and organisational role within the constituency and beyond. The way the party presents it this will be a brilliant example of teamwork. As Fearghal puts it "I believe that Tommy Gallagher's experience married with my ideas and plans for organisation and structures are a winning combination."

So no truth then, to the widespread assumption that the TV personality stood in the Westminster election in the hope/assumption that he would inherit the assembly seat from the 68 year old Mr Gallagher? Tommy is quoted as arguing that "this Assembly has failed many sections of society - young people in general. They are now left with poor job prospects despite the great initiative and enthusiasm they show in developing their own projects." Just to re-iterate: he is talking about young people in general, not Fearghal in particular.

Thanks, but no thanks

Mark Devenport | 09:28 UK time, Thursday, 20 January 2011

Comments

There's more than a suspicion that when backbench MLAs ask a minister from their own party a question they have more than an inkling what the answer will be. Maybe, perish the thought, the minister has even suggested to the backbencher that a particular query would be helpful.

So when Michelle McIlveen was called to ask Arlene Foster for an update on the potential reduction in the level of local corporation tax she got a bit ahead of herself, and began by thanking the DETI minister for an answer she hadn't yet delivered. Ms McIlveen realised her mistake, sat back down, then got up again after the minister had finished with the words: "Take two; thank you. My face is probably the same colour as my jacket..."

Don't sit on your phone

Mark Devenport | 09:20 UK time, Thursday, 20 January 2011

Comments

Ever inadvertently rung someone from your mobile? It's easy to do if you don't lock your handset. But the consequences can be disastrous. When the former UUP MLA David McClarty resigned from his party he revealed that a colleague had accidentally left a message describing the East Londonderry politician as "a spent force". Today's has a blow by blow account of who said what to whom which should be a cringeable read for those involved.

Secrets and Cash

Mark Devenport | 15:59 UK time, Monday, 17 January 2011

Comments

So you hold a consultation to ask the public what you should do about something. 77% of them tell you to pick Option A. 12% back Option B. What do you do? Well, of course, if you are the NIO, you pick Option B.

That's the outcome of the NIO's

Option A - full transparency - was backed by Sinn Fein, Alliance, the Greens, the National Union of Journalists and various members of the public.

Option B - keeping the names of donors secret for another two years - was supported by the DUP and the UUP.

And I forgot to mention Option C - a bit more transparency but still no names for two years. It was backed by a further 12% (which brings our total to 101%), including the SDLP and the Electoral Commission.

The reason given by the NIO for rejecting the arguments of the 77% in favour of open government is that "it is clear that there has been a deterioration in the overall security situation in Northern Ireland in recent years. We believe that there remains a case for protecting donor identities for a further two years and will bring forward legislation to
provide for this."

The names of political donors had been due to be revealed when the current legislation expires in March. However the cloak of anonymity will now be extended until 2013.

There and Back Again

Mark Devenport | 10:15 UK time, Friday, 14 January 2011

Comments

Returned to County Down in the early hours after a quick jaunt down to Dublin for what turned out to be an abortive heave on Brian Cowen. For a few hours, the atmospherics felt similar to the days leading up to the fall of Albert Reynolds in the mid nineties.

However we didn't scale the heights of rumour counter, rumour and conspiracy theory reached then, when at every other moment we were hearing about potential developments which would shake both the state and the church to their cores (after one particularly imaginative intervention from Pat Rabbitte the then Guardian correspondent David Sharrock wrote memorably that the Dublin South West TD had become "the first Rabbitte to pull a red herring out of a top hat").

Instead it all petered out quickly, with the Fianna Fail party willing to give Mr Cowen more time, even though the Dubliners I chatted to on Grafton Street were almost unanimous in expressing the view that he should have resigned long ago.

Around 18 months ago I drove south to report on a rash of resignations from Sinn Fein's ranks. Now by contrast the party is going from strength to strength - winning the Donegal by-election, performing well in the opinion polls, their new TD Pearse Doherty impressing in his Dail interventions on the budget and now Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin scoring points on his interrogation of Mr Cowen over the Anglo Irish golf outing.

How low will Fianna Fail go when Irish voters finally get the chance to cast their verdicts on the financial mess the state is in? And how much of a gap will there be between the size of the Fianna Fail party in the next Dail and the strength of the Sinn Fein group?

Uisce, uisce achan áit !

Mark Devenport | 15:45 UK time, Tuesday, 11 January 2011

Comments

Conor Murphy's Regional Development department has just launched a

Cue the predictable reaction: the DUP's Michelle McIlveen thinks it's a "waste of public money on a pointless political exercise". Alliance's Judith Cochrane worries that the "proposals will essentially implement a tribal, ghettoising carve-up of an area". But Mr Murphy's party colleague the new West Belfast MLA Pat Sheehan reckons it's "a welcome development and one that will enable local councils to erect signage in Irish or Ulster Scots." In Mr Sheehan's view the move is "another step in the right direction in meeting the Executive commitments under the European Charter for the protection of minority languages".

Finding common ground on this is always tough, but here's a proposal. If we could identify the places where bowsers are likely to be located during the next water crisis, maybe the new revamped NIW Communications department can shell out for
tri-lingual signs to leave consumers in no doubt where to find much needed uisce, watter or water. As Myles Na Gopaleen might have put, having an crúiscín lán (the full jug), is better than having none.

Eat Your Greens!

Mark Devenport | 14:54 UK time, Monday, 10 January 2011

Comments

If you want to be big and strong - if you don't, you might end up like me or Steven Agnew!

At a Green Party news conference in Stormont today there was some debate amongst the camera operators as to whether the newly elected leader Steven Agnew should stand or sit - which led a non-politically correct wag to quip "oh I thought you were standing".

Now as Political Editor I have to maintain complete impartiality. But as a pocket sized correspondent I'm on the barricades together with the new Green leader against this blatant height-ism.

Steven and I have resolved to form a new alliance for vertically challenged political anoraks at Stormont. We shall refuse any complimentary tickets we are offered to the all Ireland basketball final, and boycott any concerts by

The former Green Euro candidate beat Cadogan Enright by 72% to 28% (eerily exactly the same ratio as that given by NI water for leaks on private property and leaks on their system).

Now Mr Agnew faces a challenge, not just from the heightists, but from voters who may have started to take the Green message for granted. He told us that after deriding the Greens as sandal wearing hippies, Sammy Wilson has now stolen their policies on the Green New Deal.

Still 2011 could be a difficult time for the Greens in Ireland - in the south they will be lucky to save any of their Dail seats as the public punish those involved in the current coalition. In the north, Steven Agnew may face a little local difficulty in North Down with the Wilson conundrum previously referred to on this blog.

If you are wondering how come the Greens have a leader either side of the border, the party says they haven't broken away - Mr Agnew will be a regional leader, but John Gormley will still be the leader across the island. Which is as it should be, I suppose, as Mr Gormley is taller.

The Two Wise Men (or Women)

Mark Devenport | 16:16 UK time, Friday, 7 January 2011

Comments

So after another marathon Executive session we now have twin inquiries into the water crisis, one from the Utility Regulator examining NI Water and one from two independent investigators probing the response of the Regional Development department.

As I write the two wise men (or women) haven't yet been identified. They will be appointed by the First and Deputy First MInisters and I am guessing they will have sufficient experience of industry or governance to inspire a degree of confidence in their ability to provide an authoritative report. However the remit they have been given in relation to the department's role seems far less specific than the remit published in relation to the Utlity Regulator's examination of NI Water. (UPDATE: They have been named as Philip Holder and Heather Moorhead - so "One Wise Man and One Wise Woman" would have been a more accurate headline.)

On the face of it, the addition of this extra component goes some way towards meeting the criticism from the Consumer Council and others that giving the job to the Utility Regulator alone was asking too much of an office which is slready part of the established governance structures here. However in its latest statement the Council still isn't impressed by what it views as a

Whatever the merits of the twin track adopted by the Executive, will the passage of time dilute the impact of the investigation? The composite report is due to go to ministers by the end of February. With the Assembly likely to rise at the end of March for the 2011 election campaign, that will only leave around four weeks for any action to be taken on the basis of the Utility Regulator and special investigators' conclusions. And who knows, under the D'Hondt method, who will pick the Regional Development brief after the May election?

I shall be talking to the Minister for Winter, Conor Murphy, on Inside Politics this weekend. Does his refusal to step aside show strength of character or a failure to fully accept his own responsibility? And would his survival have been possible under any other system of government? That's all on 91Èȱ¬ Radio Ulster's Inside Politics this Sunday after the one o'clock news.

P.S. Throughout this crisis Sinn Fein backbenchers have been taking swipes at the Housing Executive's handling of the big freeze, whilst SDLP politicians have been concentrating their fire on the hapless NI Water. The DUP have happily fired at both targets (the Social Development chair Simon Hamilton expressed his surprise today about the fact that nearly a quarter of Housing Executive homes needed repairs after the thaw). Many of the concerns expressed are legitimate, but I'd like to ask readers to keep an eye out for any backbencher who steels their courage to launch a blistering assault on a government agency answerable to a department led by a minister from their own party. That would be a bit different - it could be the Stormont equivalent to listening out for the first cuckoo of the spring.

Next - a plague of frogs?

Mark Devenport | 12:38 UK time, Tuesday, 4 January 2011

Comments

First snow, then water - what next? A friend suggested to me we must be in for a plague of frogs.

Today's Irish News reckons the NI Water Chief Executive Laurence McKenzie won't last the week. Certainly when I was hanging around outside Stormont Castle after last Thursday's Executive meeting, there seemed precious little evidence of ministerial support for the Chief Executive (even though earlier in the day Conor Murphy had told the Nolan Show he had confidence in Mr McKenzie). The signs are that things may be moving fast on this score, with the Northern Ireland Water board meeting again this afternoon.

The Regional Development Department is meant to be forwarding the terms of reference for its investigation into the water crisis to the First and Deputy First Ministers today. That doesn't mean they will be published, as OFMDFM will have to approve them first, but an announcement is expected sooner rather than later. Stormont's Regional Development Committee is due to hold a hearing on the debacle on Thursday morning.

There's little doubt that serious errors were made by Northern Ireland Water's senior management. But there's also the question of how much responsibility Minister Murphy should take himself.The Minister can't hire and fire the Chief Executive. However, as he proved during the saga over NI Water's procurement practices, he can get rid of the Chairman and the board. So did the minister use his power too readily in the face of irregularities in the company's internal procedures regarding multi million pound contracts, and has it come back to haunt him in the shape of what ordinary consumers might regard as a graver crisis?

The TUV's Jim Allister was the first to call for Minister Murphy to go. He has since been joined by the Ulster Unionist leader Tom Elliott and the DUP Finance Minister Sammy Wilson. Is this the least that should be expected, or, as Sinn Fein's John O'Dowd claims, 'pathetic politicking at a time when ordinary people are suffering'?

Beyond the question of which heads should roll rises the debate about how investment can be generated to update NI water's infrastructure. Alliance was a lone voice at Stormont in advocating water charges, and the UUP deputy leader John McAllister came in for a battering when he talked about the possibility on the radio. But will the water crisis change the nature of the debate?

Last week Martin McGuinness dismissed the introduction of charges, suggesting that "well heeled economists" who advocate that should consider making their own voluntary contributions to Stormont. An effective bit of rhetoric, but not a long term answer to the scrabble for much needed capital funding.

Although Owen Paterson offered UK help when it came to emergency assistance with the water crisis, there was no sign of any movement on fresh capital to make up for historic under investment in the water system here during the direct rule era. Instead the Secretary of State defended George Osborne's allocation to Stormont as "very fair".

If there's one thing less popular with voters than paying for water, then it has to be not having any water at all. By the time the Assembly election comes in May, the memories of the winter water crisis may have receded. But the Stormont parties will still face a major challenge proving devolution can deliver something rather better than the confusion and delay over the provision of basic amenities we have all witnessed in recent days.

91Èȱ¬ iD

91Èȱ¬ navigation

91Èȱ¬ © 2014 The 91Èȱ¬ is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.