91Èȱ¬

91Èȱ¬ BLOGS - The Devenport Diaries

Archives for January 2009

Assembly Voting Records

Mark Devenport | 15:50 UK time, Friday, 30 January 2009

Comments

After the recent figues on Committee attendance, the DUP has obtained figures from the Assembly business office on how often MLAs vote. Lord Morrow claims the party leads the way in voting, whilst taking a swipe at the UUP in general and David Burnside in particular, as, according to the figures, the South Antrim MLA participated in less than a quarter of Assembly votes.

Here's the DUP figures:

VOTING RECORD OF ASSEMBLY MEMBERS

PERIOD - MAY 2007 - 20TH JANUARY 2009-01-30
89 DIVISIONS

AVERAGE VOTING RECORD OF EACH PARTY
DUP - 84.2%
SF - 77.6%
UUP - 67.5%
SDLP - 71.6%
ALL - 69.3%
GREEN - 68.5%
PUP - 29.2%
IND - DEENEY - 23.6%
IND - McHUGH - 29.2%

I am putting the raw data from the Business Office in the extended entry.

Read the rest of this entry

Sylvia, Owen and Dave too

Mark Devenport | 15:20 UK time, Friday, 30 January 2009

Comments

Lady Sylvia Hermon has been taking a break from active politics since the death of her husband, the former RUC Chief Constable Sir John Hermon. But I'm told that the North Down MP will meet the Conservative leader David Cameron next month to discuss the courtship between their parties. Given that Lady Sylvia has appeared cool on the idea, and has a voting record which favours the Labour party, it should be an interesting encounter.

My guest on Inside Politics this weekend is the Conservative spokesman Owen Paterson. I ask him about the UUP link, the Eames Bradley proposals and how he intends to handle next week's Westminster Committee meeting on the extension of the law which underpins General de Chastelain's decommissioning team. At the last Northern Ireland question time in the Commons many MPs were sceptical about giving loyalist paramilitaries another year to disarm. But since then the Secretary of State has indicated he would be ready to rescind the law if no progress is made in the next six months.

Inside Politics is on Radio Ulster at 12.45 pm on Saturday, or (if our technicians have fixed the recent fault) via the programme's webpage.

My colleague Kevin Sharkey has more on the prospects for loyalist disarmament on the Politics Show in Sunday. That's on 91Èȱ¬1 at noon.

Bairbre's boxing gloves

Mark Devenport | 15:13 UK time, Friday, 30 January 2009

Comments

All the predictions are that this summer's European election is going to be a bare knuckle fight. Maybe that's why Bairbre De Brun is getting in some early sparring practice, appearing at Ligoniel Boxing Club this weekend alongside women's world champion, Katie Taylor. Has anyone taught Alban to duck?

No phoenix, just ashes

Mark Devenport | 16:03 UK time, Thursday, 29 January 2009

Comments

The multi sports stadium was due to to rise from the ashes of the Maze jail as a symbol if a new Northern Ireland. But as my colleague Gareth Gordon revealed that direct rule dream has now been laid to rest by the Culture Minister Gregory Campbell. Will his plan to fund sports venues separately go smoothly, or run into objections from Sinn Fein and the GAA?

I'm just back from the Stormont Executive which didn't agree to put the minister's Maze paper on its agenda. Mr Campbell arrived without commenting on the stadium, then left early for a Rally Ireland event in Enniskillen. So no olympic soccer then but not to worry because Fermanagh is the new Monaco (if the Culture Department's news releases are to be believed).

Executive ministers could give master classes in how not to discuss pressing matters. This afternoon they also declined to consider or vote on Caitriona Ruane's latest proposals on replacing the eleven plus.

There are some minor modifications, such as giving "looked after children" first priority and confirming the minister's plan for schools to meet a quota of children entitled to free school meals. But in truth the minister's paper is mainly a reiteration of her previous offer of a three year phase out for academic selection.

Emerging from the Executive, Ms Ruane accused the DUP of blocking her proposals and vowed not to bring forward any new initiative. Instead she says she will have discussions with her officials and act decisively in the days ahead. That sounds like code for issuing guidelines which will not be as binding as any legal regulations approved by the Executive.

With the majority of grammar schools already making preparations for go it alone tests, this afternoon felt like the beginning of an "unregulated regime" for post primary transfer. Whichever side of the argument over academic selection you take, it's a worrying prospect: potential educational anarchy and pupils and teachers being used as political pawns.

The Ballroom of Dissonance

Mark Devenport | 13:34 UK time, Wednesday, 28 January 2009

Comments

So did all roads lead here? To a grand ballroom in the Europa hotel. Once it was Europe's most bombed hotel. Today, crystal chandeliers glinted above us whilst all around sat people representative of every shade of hurt caused by the troubles.

The Eames Bradley launch was no ordinary news conference, rather a microcosm of the conflict of the last four decades. Before it began the relatives of IRA victims and loyalist victims argued in front of the cameras. Jim Allister was amongst a number of people holding placards at the back emblazoned "the wages of murder is £12,000". A couple of feet from me stood victims campaigner Hazlett Lynch holding up a big picture of his brother, Constable Kenneth Norman Lynch, who was murdered by the IRA in 1977.

Before the proceedings got underway, the former unionist MLA Cedric Wilson (once known as the "serial protestor") turned his ire on Gerry Adams. Was this man a victim or a perpetrator, he asked Lord Eames, who did not answer. It was the first of several interruptions from Mr Wilson.

After a brief endorsement from the South African mediator Brian Currin, the report's two principal co-authors made their pitch. It helped that they are both experienced preachers and orators. Before such a divided audience the surprise wasn't that they were interrupted, but that they commanded a respectful hearing for so long.

They apologised for the timing of their recommendation that all families of troubles victims should get £12,000, but not for the proposal itself. Denis Bradley stressed that the money wasn't intended as compensation but as recognition - a way of telling the families that society is "sorry for their troubles".

Besides defending their suggested payments, the authors sketched out their ideas for a five year £160 million legacy commission. They aren't proposing an amnesty but leaving it to the commission to suggest how a line might be drawn at the end of its term.

Lord Eames and Mr Bradley went beyond victims issues. Their suggested £100 million bursary scheme should tackle social problems like sectarianism, trauma and addiction. They even questioned whether separate schools for those of different denominations act as an obstacle to reconciliation.

They accused the local parties of politicising victims issues. It's as if, Denis Bradley argued, the parties were allowed to have a political accommodation up at Stormont but the people were not allowed to have a human accommodation.

It was powerful stuff, although the pictures of the exchanges between victims campaigners are likely to dominate the TV news bulletins. At one point it looked like the presentations might be halted, but eventually the speakers pressed on. Bizarrely, nationalists in the audience were demanding that the police step in to arrest or take out the protesting unionists. "Where's Hugh Orde?" they cried, then with typical Belfast humour someone added "no wonder he didn't get the job". The Chief Constable was sitting in the audience.

So where do we go from here? The Prime Minister and the Secretary of State have a holding line that the report should be carefully considered. Unless the mood changes in the weeks ahead, there doesn't seem to be any sign of a consensus in favour of the £12,000 payments.

If the money is not intended as compensation, but as recognition, surely the question arises whether some other public form of recognition might win support which does not involve a wad of cash? For example, the Eames Bradley report explores the possibility of a video archive of stories, perhaps in a museum, but concludes that a shared memorial cannot be agreed at this time. Handled sensitively, would giving every family a chance to be part of such a "living memorial" be a better way of saying "sorry for your troubles" than £12,000?

The government might find it easier to park the contentious payments and move ahead with the legacy commission and the bursary. However, given the economic climate, MPs might still baulk at the projected £260 million price tag.

The report's authors argue that their ideas would actually save money as continuing with piece meal inquiries might cost as much as £1 billion. But after the Saville inquiry experience, few politicians believe any further inquiries will be approved. If the government adopts the Westminster Northern Ireland Affairs Committee's recommendation that all future inquiries should have cross community support from the Assembly, unionists would probably veto any such probes.

So the financial case has yet to be concluded. And bearing in mind the fractious scenes in the Europa hotel ballroom, the government will think long and hard before deciding how many of the Eames Bradley recommendations might command a political consensus.

In storage

Mark Devenport | 17:08 UK time, Tuesday, 27 January 2009

Comments

During the period of suspension there used to be talk about the Stormont institutions being kept in "warm storage". Now the round table the old Executive used to sit around in Room 21 has itself been carried off into storage. as previously noted here Edwin Poots has beenasking about the round table's whereabouts. He says the rectangular table which has replaced it is a piece of flat pack furniture unsuitable for an historic building.

"Get used to it"

Mark Devenport | 16:50 UK time, Tuesday, 27 January 2009

Comments

The Financial Assistance Bill passed its final stage today. This morning's discussions, whilst they wouldn't have been new to those who sat through previous lengthy proceedings, were illuminating as a synopsis of the tortured relations within the Executive.

Yesterday, and again today, Alex Attwood made much of Carál Ní Chuilín's retort that the SDLP should "get used to it". He viewed that as a reference to the two dominant parties bulldozering measures through, despite the objections of their partners. The Sinn Fein Chief Whip said she was just talking about her party's response to an "incompetent" minister.

Peter Robinson said that if a "man from mars" had witnessed the exchanges over the bill he would have been amazed to find out that it dealt with getting much needed help to vulnerable people. Barry McElduff accused the junior partners of "negativity for negativity's sake".

All in all another normal working day in the fractious coalition.
.

A Cure For Insomnia

Mark Devenport | 17:14 UK time, Monday, 26 January 2009

Comments

Daithi McKay asked the Assembly Commission about the possibility of putting video of the chamber proceedings on Youtube, but Basil McCrea wanted to go further. Shouldn't the assembly have its own dedicated satellite TV channel, he suggested, as its proceedings had the makings of a good soap opera.

The chair, David McClarty did not appear convinced. "At last a cure for insomnia" he quipped before moving to the next speaker.

What did Aunt Mabel give you 2?

Mark Devenport | 12:47 UK time, Monday, 26 January 2009

Comments

Earlier this month we reported Thomas Burns' question to the First and Deputy First Ministers about Christmas gifts they sent or received. The ministers say they did not distribute Christmas gifts, but each received a stationery set.

Raw emotion in Armagh

Mark Devenport | 15:34 UK time, Saturday, 24 January 2009

Comments

I've been covering the SDLP conference in Armagh today. Unlike the Ulster Unionists, who had David Cameron as a star turn at their gathering, the SDLP did not have any rabbits to pull out of their hats. Dermot Ahern sat in the audience, as one of a number of observers, but any prospect of a Fianna Fail merger is now dead in the water.

Instead the party seemed to be concentrating on its core values, stressing that it is the party people can trust to deliver in Stormont, Westminster and Europe. Margaret Ritchie was again the SDLP supporters' darling, whilst Alban Maginness (campaign slogan Maginness is good for EU) kick started his Euro campaign. Introduced by Gerry Conlon as "a man who stays true to his word", Mark Durkan put in a solid performance, less impassioned than he has been in the past.

His best cracks were about Bairbre De Brun (some want to challenge her record as an MEP, "but that might be seen as attacking someone's private life") and the DUP's choice of a candidate ("an unprecedented, radical departure. Let's run an MP's wife").

Despite all of this, the SDLP will face an uphill struggle reclaiming its European seat, given the likely contest between Sinn Fein and the DUP to top the poll. Although it is undoubtedly true that the party is far more pro Europe than the incumbents, appeals to the legacy of John Hume sound like the same old story.

Outside the main conference hall the headlines are likely to be captured by the raw emotion on display from Paul Quinn's mother, Briege, at a fringe meeting. She talked about how every bone in her son's body had been broken by his murderers, and how despite the denials from Conor Murphy and Gerry Adams she remained convinced the IRA carried out the killing.

Wiping tears away from her face, Mrs Quinn talked of how she thought of the shed where her son was tortured and killed every minute of every day and would never get it out of her mind.

As the political discussion concentrates on the Eames Bradley proposals about how to deal with the past, it was a vivid reminder that for people like Briege Quinn who have lost someone in tragic circumstances the past is the present.

A waste of time?

Mark Devenport | 17:38 UK time, Friday, 23 January 2009

Comments

That was Peter Robinson's verdict on initial reports about the Eames Bradley group on the past. Unionists have set their heads against the proposed £12,000 payment to the families of all those killed in the troubles, irrespective of their status. Nationalists appear more ready to give the payments, and proposals for a three person Legacy Commission, a fairer wind.

So is the payment scheme creating an equivalence between IRA members and loyalists and innocent civilians? Or given that any money would go to their families not the victims themselves (who are of course no longer with us) then are the tears of a bomber's mother equal to the tears of another victim's mother?

And given the £40 million price tag for the "recognition payments" will Gordon Brown fund the scheme or not.

With SDLP supporters gathering in Armagh for their annual conference, my guest on Inside Politics tomorrow is Mark Durkan. I spend the first half of the programme gauging his reaction to the Eames Bradley proposals.

On another day the news that Diane Dodds has emerged as the hot favourite for the DUP European nomination would have been taking up more of my time. But this has been a busy Friday.

Tomorrow I shall join Jim Fitzpatrick for live coverage of the SDLP conference on 91Èȱ¬2 from 11.;45 am. Inside Politics is on 91Èȱ¬ radio Ulster at the usual time of 12.45 pm.


A revolving door?

Mark Devenport | 15:24 UK time, Thursday, 22 January 2009

Comments

The SDLP's Dolores Kelly is concerned about the amount of money being spent on re-hiring recently retired civil servants as consultants. She's received figures showing that £424,248 was spent on the services of 30 or so retired civil servants over the last five years. Ms Kelly wonders why their skills and expertise are not available amongst the permanent civil service staff.

That's All Folks!

Mark Devenport | 12:07 UK time, Thursday, 22 January 2009

Comments

Much talk in the Stormont canteen this week, not about the Financial Assistance Bill or the Obama inauguration, but about the 91Èȱ¬'s decision to drop the TV version of the "Folks On The Hill". Most of the politicians featured profess to like their caricatures, although maybe they are just too savvy to reveal any annoyance. Sean Crummey's mimicry will still be heard on Radio Ulster, but I, for one, will miss the TV version. Has anyone out there a favourite sketch?

Pork Barrel Politics

Mark Devenport | 16:38 UK time, Wednesday, 21 January 2009

Comments

A Conservative MP accused the PM and the DUP of engaging in over last year's vote on the proposed 42 day detention of terror suspects and the subsequent approval of financial support for the East Belfast firm Bombardier. The Secretary of State rejected the charge pointing out the general benefits of the jobs created by the company.

"Pork barrel politics" of a different kind will be under discussion in Londonderry on Friday when the First and Deputy First Ministers meet Brian Cowen for a full meeting of the North South Ministerial Council. Rather than setting up its own compensation package for the farmers whose herds are suspected of dioxin contamination, the Executive says it will chase the Irish authorities as the suspect feed originated south of the border. So pork and beef are likely to feature at the discussions, as well as the general state of the economy.

The full facts of the dioxin scare are yet to be established. But the Irish may well point to suspicions that oil involved in the contamination came from north of the border as a reason to bat the Executive away.

Either way the TUV MEP Jim Allister reckons there could be a problem so far as Europe is concerned. He has discussed the matter with the Agriculture Commissioner Marian Fischer-Boel and is doubtful whether Northern Ireland can benefit from a compensation package approved for the Republic. Mr Allister is concerned that the Executive is wasting time "chasing a moonbeam".

The argument over whether the Executive should pay compensation to the farmers reached the high court today, where the owners of five herds are seeking a judicial review.

Loyalists to Disarm?

Mark Devenport | 16:25 UK time, Wednesday, 21 January 2009

Comments

Shaun Woodward found himself under considerable pressure during Northern Ireland question time today, with the Conservatives, Liberal Democrats, DUP, SDLP and even some of his own backbenchers putting him on notice that they will oppose the extension of the law which grants paramilitaries immunity from prosecution for holding weapons if they are seeking to decommission them voluntarily.

The Secretary of State defended his position by insisting that General John De Chastelain's Commission was looking for another year because it was involved in meanigful dialogue with loyalists which could soon lead to guns being taken off the street.

Other MPs didn't seem convinced, but Mr Woodward would only share any further evidence he had with his opposite number, Owen Paterson, through the

Late Nights, Rows and Mr Jelly

Mark Devenport | 13:23 UK time, Wednesday, 21 January 2009

Comments

My colleagues on Today at the Assembly had their work cut out last night as the Stormont proceedings ran on until nearly 10 pm shortly before they were due on air. Gareth Gordon hung on until the end. I ducked out early as I was due on Good Morning Ulster at 7 am.

At one point we had the Obama inauguration on one screen in the press room and the Assembly chamber on the other. It was slightly bizarre as the cheers and jeers of the MLAs and "order, order" from the Speaker mingled with the rhetoric from Capitol Hill.

During the lengthy debate on the Financial Assistance Bill there were a number of clashes between the SDLP and the DUP. if you examine the you can see that at 12.30 pm. the First Minister crossed swords with Declan O'Loan over whether the SDLP MLA had accused him of being deceitful. When he didn't like the response from the Deputy Speaker after taking advice from the Clerk, the First Minister went on "maybe you will tell your Clerk to listen more carefully before he gives you such advice, because the person who is bringing forward this measure is myself, and if a deceit is being perpetrated, it can only be by the person who is bringing it forward."

Later Mr Robinson clashed with the SDLP Leader Mark Durkan. Between 3.30 pm and 3.45 pm Mr Robinson told MLAs that Margaret Ritchie had led her Executive colleagues to believe that she already had the power to make fuel poverty payments without requiring legislation. After 4 pm Mark Durkan challenged this brandishing an Executive paper which he claims proved Mr Robinson's statement was inaccurate. He accused the First Minister of misleading the Assembly, a use of language which can get an MLA thrown out if they can't justify its use. SDLP sources produced ministerial rules saying all ministers must give the Assembly accurate information, or if not they should resign.

Much later, between 7.30 pm and 8 pm the Speaker Willie Hay ruled on the matter. Without naming the First Minister he reminded MLAs that it was not in order to refer to the Assembly officials. He then said he would be calling on Mark Durkan to withdraw his remarks at the earliest opportunity. The SDLP objected to the Speaker naming Mr Durkan but not Mr Robinson.

If Mark Durkan refuses to withdraw, then he is likely to be suspended from the Assembly on Monday. However it's possible he could alter his words sufficiently to avoid walking the Stormont plank. But as the SDLP question the facts underlying the ruling and what they see as the asymmetric nature of the Speaker's judgement they say they won't let the matter rest.

The details of this parliamentary spat are arcane. In general terms, however, it's another illustration of the dysfunctional nature of the Stormont coalition in which the smaller parties are increasingly an opposition within.

So where does the jelly come in? Well in the final stage of the Public Authorities (Reform) Bill, by which time Willie Hay's head was probably well and truly turned, the Speaker introduced a hitherto unheard of minister, namely Mr Jelly.

With laughter all around, Gerry Kelly thanked the Speaker for giving him a new name.

Long John Adams

Mark Devenport | 17:04 UK time, Tuesday, 20 January 2009

Comments

Jim Fitzpatrick spoke to Gerry Adams for "Stormont Live" today as he prepared to watch Barack Obama's inauguration. With Washington in a mid winter freeze, the Sinn Fein President told Jim he was in his "long johns". Forget Long John Silver. Meet Long John Adams.

Grilling Yourself

Mark Devenport | 17:02 UK time, Monday, 19 January 2009

Comments

Sinn Fein's Paul Butler is the member of the Assembly Commission responsible for engaging with the wider community. Next week he has tabled an oral question asking the Commission how it plans to obtain the views of MLAs on its engagement strategy.

Officials are scratching their heads about how to handle this, as there appears to be a real possibility that the Lagan Valley MLA might have to answer his own question. Given that, in his past life as an IRA prisoner, Mr Butler was no doubt trained on withstanding questioning, this could make interesting viewing.

UPDATE: MY sources tell me the question has now been withdrawn.

Plugging a book in the Philippines

Mark Devenport | 16:13 UK time, Monday, 19 January 2009

Comments

We just talked to Gerry Kelly on Stormont Live about his conflict resolution trip to He was accompanied by Tony Blair's former Chief of Staff Jonathan Powell. He told us the two men were driven through rebel held territory along tracks lined by armed militants from the Moro Islamic Liberation Front. When they arrived, they were greeted by a MILF leader who was leafing through a copy of Jonathan Powell's book, "Great Hatred, Little Room". It must be doing great trade in the Mindanao bookstores.

The Latent Liberalistos

Mark Devenport | 15:14 UK time, Friday, 16 January 2009

Comments

Both the DUP and Alliance have seized on David McNarry's criticism this morning of "The Latent Wide Boy Lliberalistos" within the local Tory party as proof of more turmoil in the UUP-Conservative courtship. May be so, but it also sounds like quite a good name for a rock band.

Cutting Departments 2

Mark Devenport | 14:35 UK time, Friday, 16 January 2009

Comments

Earlier in the week I noted the DUP's motion on reducing government departments, which is due for debate on Monday. Given Lord Digby Jones' comments on firing civil servants, it seemed a good time to debate this on Inside Politics. My guests are the DUP's Simon Hamilton and the SDLP's Alex Attwood and the programme is on as usual at a quarter to one on 91Èȱ¬ Radio Ulster or, subsequently, via the programme website.

Clawing Back on Bloody Sunday

Mark Devenport | 18:09 UK time, Thursday, 15 January 2009

Comments

The Security Minister Paul Goggins told MPs today that his officials have been working closely with the Bloody Sunday inquiry secretariat to try to make some savings even at this late stage. He hopes to announce several hundred thousands of pounds of savings on areas such as accommodation. I have a vision of M'Learned friends being ordered to move to a camping site somewhere on the North West coast. Probably not. Any savings made have to be viewed in the context of the latest cost of the Saville inquiry, estimated at £185.7 million until the end of December.

Winding up the SDLP

Mark Devenport | 18:01 UK time, Thursday, 15 January 2009

Comments

A DUP politician showed an SDLP colleague an official looking pamphlet today proclaiming "Morrow is Your Man for Europe". So was this the answer to the question mark over who the DUP will confirm, after some delay, as their candidate to take on Jim Allister?

No, my DUP sources tell me it was a wind up. The pamphlet dated from Maurice Morrow's unsuccessful candidacy , before Jim Allister's selection by the DUP.

On the topic of Mr Allister, the TUV leader appears to be competing with Iris Robinson for next year's "Stonewall" prize for anti-gay views.

In a debate on civil partnerships he told fellow Euro MPs, "the natural order is man and woman. We pervert it when we demand equality for its very antithesis. Unfashionable as it may be, I unashamedly declare that the unnatural partnership between same sex couples is not something to which I as a legislator consent."

A word from the First Minister

Mark Devenport | 17:51 UK time, Thursday, 15 January 2009

Comments

Kevin Sharkey has been working on a piece for this weekend's Politics Show on what can be done to improve the question time at Stormont. He found it difficult to secure an interview with our First Minister, but straightforward to catch a word with his Scottish counterpart Alex Salmond. You can hear Mr Salmond's views on the importance of regular question times on Good Morning Ulster tomorrow morning then on the Politics Show on Sunday.

What did Aunt Mabel give you?

Mark Devenport | 17:27 UK time, Wednesday, 14 January 2009

Comments

Thanks to commenter PJCavehill for bringing my attention to this question from the SDLP's Thomas Burns "To ask the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister to detail all Christmas gifts they sent and received."

I am assuming Mr Burns' query is limited to any official gifts to or from the Office, but I'd like to think Peter and Martin could extend their reply so we discover all the wooly jumpers the Junior Ministers got from their relatives. Let's hope they kept a good note of who gave what.

On a separate note the local banks weren't giving a lot away when they gave evidence to the Finance Committee today. They are, it appears, hard working types doing the best for their community against a backdrop of global financial meltdown.

It took 8 weeks for the Finance Committee to persuade them to appear. Its members seemed fairly satisfied that the meeting took place at all, rather than insisting on getting much concrete out of it. The bankers were asked about mortgages, credit cards, overdrafts and loans to small businesses.

During one exchange (appropriately enough between Banker Eric Leenders and MLA Declan O'Loan) the banks were accused of not doing enough to fund independent debt advice like that provided by the CAB. The Committee chair, Mitchel McLaughlin, says the bankers have agreed to come back to the politicians on a number of points and if they don't provide satisfaction the committee will return to "the politics of confrontation".

Tough talk, but with yet more depressing news about Nortel and Seagate how much can Stormont politicians do to ameliorate the impact of the credit crunch?

Justice and Cutting Stormont's Departments

Mark Devenport | 17:13 UK time, Tuesday, 13 January 2009

Comments

MLAs will debate the Assembly and Executive Review Committee's latest report on policing and justice next Tuesday. The TUV's Jim Allister has seen a draft and remains unhappy that the Judicial Appointments Commission will be the responsibility of the OFMDFM, thus in his view still linking Martin McGuinness to the appointment of judges. DUP sources play this down, pointing out that there is not due to be any re-appointments to the Commission until 2012.

The report - as Mr Allister points out - still leaves the question of whether a future Justice Minister should be in or out of the Executive undecided. At one stage the DUP was against making the minister an Executive member for fear that their Executive colleagues could use the St. Andrews rules to curtail their independence (code for Sinn Fein using its power over justice issues). So this is one yet to be clarified.

I'm told the Secretary of State has turned down a request from the Committee for a copy of the protocols he is working on with the OFMDFM over what access a new minister might have to sensitive security matters.

Atlhough the First and Deputy First Ministers say there should be no undue delay in devolving justice we are still none the wiser on when this might happen. One source suggested to me today that November might be a possibility.

Adding a Justice department will once again open up the whole question of whether, with 14 ministers and 11 departments, we already have too many departments at Stormont. It's understood the Assembly Executive and Review Committee has agreed to consider this and a DUP motion in favour of reducing the number of departments has been tabled for debate on Monday.
.

Tudor Crisps

Mark Devenport | 16:46 UK time, Tuesday, 13 January 2009

Comments

Illustrating his concern that the First and Deputy First Ministers could use their Financial Assistance Bill in a power grab on other departments, Danny Kennedy talked about "Henry VIII powers".

Peter Robinson denied he was acting like a despotic monarch, retorting that the Ulster Unionist Deputy Leader knew as much about Tudor Monarchs as he did about Tudor Crisps.

The Financial Assistance Bill is the vehicle by which the Executive intends to make fuel poverty payments to 100,000 vulnerable households. But it could be used in future crises.

The SDLP and Alliance have expressed concern that the powers could be used to railroad ministers. The SDLP is particularly worried about Clause 2 of the Bill which deals with poverty and social exclusion. They suspect this could lead to interference with the Social Development brief of their minister Margaret Ritchie. Peter Robinson replies that the bill talks about poverty in particular because it deals with financial assistance intended to alleviate hardship.

Despite that the bill sailed through its stages today. Next week we shall find out if the OFMDFM is willing to accept any amendments.

(P.S. For the legal eagles amongst you, I gather that a "Henry VIII power" is a power in a bill which enables primary legislation to be amended or repealed by secondary legislation with or without further parliamentary scrutiny.)



Buying the bases

Mark Devenport | 12:06 UK time, Tuesday, 13 January 2009

Comments

Looking back at the of yesterday's First Minister's Questions, I was struck by Peter Robinson talking about the possibility of the Executive buying disused military bases. The First Minister insists he remains hopeful that London will give the bases as a free gift. However he went on to talk about the possibility of buying the sites at a reduced rate in the light of the recent collapse in property prices. No doubt that concession to the possibility of a purchase will be noted in London.

In contrast to previous assertions by Shaun Woodward, Mr Robinson rejected the notion that the delay in developing the Maze had impacted on the negotiations over the other sites. Later, during Culture Questions, Gregory Campbell, said he would be presenting a paper on the Maze to the Executive "in the very very near future."

Eradicating the Jim Virus

Mark Devenport | 17:49 UK time, Monday, 12 January 2009

Comments

Off the back of a question about people requesting treatment for flu, Jim Shannon asks the Health Minister a series of "catch all" queries. "In respect of the last year (i) what is the scale of viruses present in the Ulster Hospital; (ii) to detail the viruses found in all hospitals; (iii) what steps were taken to eradicate the viruses; and (iv) if they have returned in the same period."

In response, Michael McGimpsey turns in a dead pan act as a secondary school science teacher. "Viruses cannot be eradicated: they are found wherever there is life and are thought to have existed since living cells first evolved."

Although I suppose that depends on whether you believe in evolution or not.


YouTube, DVDs and Accordions

Mark Devenport | 11:52 UK time, Friday, 9 January 2009

Comments

Whilst Gerry Adams has started blogging, since last month the DUP's Sammy Wilson has become a regular Sinn Fein's Daithi McKay has written to the Assembly Commission suggesting it should put Question Time and other assembly business up on YouTube to ensure the public has easy access to the footage. Sounds like competition for our own "Stormont Live" which is back on air at 2.30 on 91Èȱ¬2 on Monday.

Meanwhile the MEP Jim Allister has released a greatest hits of speeches to the European parliament, together with a rousing accompaniment from the Dunloy Accordion Band.

Jim Allister will be one of my guests on tomorrow's Inside Politics, together with Sinn Fein's John O'Dowd. The two politicians will debate the bloodshed in Gaza and whether the Northern Ireland experience in conflict transformation is relevant to the Middle East.
As usual we are on air at 12.45pm on Saturday on 91Èȱ¬ Radio Ulster, or subsequently via the listen again facility.

An oily Craigavon

Mark Devenport | 11:25 UK time, Friday, 9 January 2009

Comments

With Assembly members back in their debating chamber on Monday, the Stormont cleaning staff have been working hard to get the building shiny and new. In the middle of this week some were spotted cleaning statue at the top of the stairs in the Great Hall with what appeared to be baby oil. So these days do we have an oleaginous state for an oleaginous people?

The Bearded Blog

Mark Devenport | 15:45 UK time, Thursday, 8 January 2009

Comments

i was chatting to Gerry Adams yesterday after interviewing him about the internal reshuffle which is seeing Pat Doherty replaced by Mary Lou McDonald as Vice President. He revealed that he had just started blogging on the

Gerry's first blog post dwells on last year's political departures, by Bertie and Ian Snr. Now that Pat Doherty is stepping down as Vice-President (if not as West Tyrone MP and MLA) I wondered whether the Party President was considering following suit. He insists that's not under consideration and that he has plenty of work to do in 2009.

Michelle and Big Cats

Mark Devenport | 12:59 UK time, Thursday, 8 January 2009

Comments

Aside from worrying about blood sports and the pork scare, Michelle Gildernew and her officials may also have to spend some time on feline matters. The SDLP's Thomas Burns has asked the minister how many 'Big Cat' sightings have been reported in each of the last 10 years.

Paula's Farewell Trip

Mark Devenport | 12:25 UK time, Thursday, 8 January 2009

Comments

I interviewed Paula Dobriansky earlier today, when she was visiting Stormont during a farewell tour of Northern Ireland. She steps down as US Special Envoy later this month when George Bush leaves office.

Ms Dobriansky was more low key than some of her predecessors, like George Mitchell, Richard Haass and Mitchell Reiss. Perhaps that was down to the relative progress that we had made here in contrast to the other envoys' terms.

She was a key player in last year's US Investment Conference. So I wondered whether the credit crunch had undone all the work she had been trying to achieve. She insisted that despite the challenging times, Northern Ireland had a lot of assets which outside investors would remain interested in.

Given the bloodshed in Gaza, I wanted to know if she thought Northern Ireland had any lessons to teach people in the Middle East. Should Israel negotiate with Hamas? the Envoy said she believed all sides wanted a ceasefire and that dialogue was the best way forward, adding that the NI experience had "great applicability".

So far as Barack Obama's incoming administration is concerned, Ms Dobriansky expresses confidence that a strong commitment to Northern Ireland will continue. Hillary Clinton is due to have confirmation hearings at Congress early next week before taking up her new job as Secretary of State. It will be interesting to see if anyone raises Northern Ireland during the discussion.


.

Hippo Bags and Rainwater Harvesting

Mark Devenport | 12:12 UK time, Thursday, 8 January 2009

Comments

Sinn Fein's Daithi McKay has asked a series of questions about turning off radiators, fitting solar panels and wind turbines and saving water at Stormont. The Assembly Commission assures him they are trying to ensure the House on the Hill is energy efficient, but adds that the latest advice from the Carbon Trust is that they should concentrate on reducing their emissions, before giving any further consideration to renewable energy.

On water, the Commission reveals that "Hippo" bags limiting the amount of water used when you flush the loo have been tried out in some Stormont toilets. However they say the "Hippo Bags" have been withdrawn from some public sector buildings because of inadequate flushing. They are investigating problems dispersing the rain which falls on the Stormont roof and may well turn to rainwater harvesting for use in the toilets.

Too much detail, I know, but if the Nolan show can fill up a large section of a recent programme on the M&S toilets then I am sure you all want to be kept infomed about what's going down the pan at Stormont.

Michelle and Blood Sports

Mark Devenport | 11:52 UK time, Thursday, 8 January 2009

Comments

The Green MLA, Brian Wilson has questioned Michelle Gildernew over whether she plans to ban hunting with dogs, in legislation that would mirror the English ban. The Agriculture Minister says her party position is that she opposes blood sports, but adds that there has been very little debate about a local ban. Although hunting and coursing is exempt from some of the provisions on cruelty contained in the 1972 Welfare of Animals Act, the minister explains that someone could still be prosecuted if they caused "unnecessary suffering" to an animal during a hunt - which I suppose begs the question of what a necessary level of suffering would be.

Another MLA concerned about country matters is the Ulster Unionist Tom Elliott who reckons there's a rise in deer poaching. The Environment Minister Sammy Wilson tells him the NI Environment Agency works closely with the PSNI on the matter.

Ian Paisley Jr. - An apology

Mark Devenport | 17:06 UK time, Wednesday, 7 January 2009

Comments

It has been brought to the 91Èȱ¬'s attention that on 5 December 2008 two readers of the 91Èȱ¬ "Devenport Diaries" blog posted comments on the entry entitled "Bush Tucker Trial Declined" regarding Mr Ian Paisley, Jr. It was unfortunate that these inappropriate comments came to be published and the 91Èȱ¬ unreservedly apologises to Mr Paisley for any damage or distress that these comments may have caused.

A politician with a sole

Mark Devenport | 15:45 UK time, Monday, 5 January 2009

Comments

Local Green Party co-chair John Barry has come to the defence of Muntadar al-Zaidi, the Iraqi journalist who flung his shoes at President Bush during a recent Baghdad news conference. Dr Barry reckons the outgoing US President should ask the Iraqi authorities to grant his assailant a pardon "in recognition of the fact that Mr. al-Zaidi merely engaged in a traditional method of communicating a political message" and it would be absurd and vindictive if the journalist's gesture was to land him in prison.

Here's to you, Mrs Robertson

Mark Devenport | 15:13 UK time, Monday, 5 January 2009

Comments

The Westminster Northern Ireland Affairs Committee took a crack at Lord Saville today over the delay and cost of the Bloody Sunday inquiry. A colleague pointed out that the Committee still lists Ian Paisley as our First Minister.

However it would be a cheap shot to make too much of this as the Committee's annual report, published today, makes it clear that it has hosted a farewell dinner for the former First Minister and taken evidence from his successor.

After all the current First Minister's wife sits on the Committee. Or does she? The Annual Report lists Committee members, including the Strangford MP, "Mrs Iris Robertson".

My Sinn Fein Doppelganger

Mark Devenport | 15:04 UK time, Monday, 5 January 2009

Comments

Back in 2007 the Belfast Telegraph discovered I had a googleganger. Now Danny Morrison reckons I have a republican doppelganger. He says that someone looked closely at the photographs on his website and spotted me on the right of the

The photo was taken in Larne in 1984 and my line of defence is that this is two years before I first set foot in Northern Ireland. But if my doppelganger cares to make themself known it would complete my alibi.

An Accelerated Start to 2009

Mark Devenport | 14:46 UK time, Monday, 5 January 2009

Comments

It's my first day back at work after the Christmas holiday and, having deleted several hundred e-mails, I now find myself back up at Stormont. I hadn't expected to be here today as the Assembly website entry for Today's Business still referred to the recess, which ended on Friday.

However MLAs have been at work today on a couple of committees. As I write the two Junior Ministers, Gerry Kelly and Jeffrey Donaldson, are giving evidence to the OFMDFM Committee about the Financial Assistance Bill which is being used as a vehicle to channel funds to those experiencing fuel poverty.

The bill is due to be introduced next week and the ministers are looking for the support of the Committee for it to be passed by accelerated passage. This would enable it to move through all its stages by the end of the month. Whilst the bill will be used for the £15 million fuel poverty programme in the first instance, the ministers are explaining that it could then be utilised for other crises, whether they are flash floods or disruption to the pork industry.

It looks like I wasn't the only one caught out by the accelerated nature of today's hearing. Sinn Fein's Barry McElduff sent his apologies, explaining that he only got word of the committee meeting this morning.

UPDATE: The Committee has agreed to support the bill being fast tracked through the Assembly, although the SDLP has expressed concerns about a "power grab" by the OFMDFM and Alliance's Naomi Long also sought assurance that measures would not be implemented over the heads of the relevant minister.

91Èȱ¬ iD

91Èȱ¬ navigation

91Èȱ¬ © 2014 The 91Èȱ¬ is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.