Prospects: Monday, 7 April, 2008
- 7 Apr 08, 10:18 AM
Liz Gibbons is today's programme producer - here's her early email to the team.
Hello
What would you like to cover today - and how would you like to cover it?
Treasury select committee report on 10p tax rate?
Chinese torch protests - how can we move this on?
Zimbabwe - is there a key interview we can push for?
Any other big bids/off agenda stories you've spotted?
We have a film from Liz Mackean about food waste.
And we have an interview with Nigel Lawson about his new book which questions whether climate change is all that much of a problem.
And the Diana inquest might end.
Liz
Comments Post your comment
Please please no more Zimbabwe for now! Enough already with that. Let's really discuss the abolition of the 10% tax band and why it is that those who try to better themselves by working are so often worse off than those who choose not to work.
Complain about this post
Why have MPs waited until now to protest about the abolition of the 10% tax band? If they wanted to stop it, why wasn't this done at the time it was announced? It's a bit late now that it's actually come into force.
Complain about this post
I would intrested to hear a discussion about MPs expenses claims or perks they get. For example i read that Tony Blairs TV Licence Fee gets paid out of the public purse. Rotten scumbags! Zimbabwe - Why won't we do (as a country) something about it. Diana - 10 years of news storys and headlines, can the media let this woman just rest in peace?
Rant over!
Complain about this post
1) MPs costs - i.e. Tony Blair uses the public purse to pay his telly licence, this is just stupid!!!
2) Zimbabwe - why do we as a country never actually bother doing something about it.
3) Diana - poor woman died 10 years ago and has never been out the media, can we just leave her to rest in peace??
4) London 2012 - who cares??? the rest of the country doesn't.
Complain about this post
The answer to Dominic Kearney's question ("Why have MPs waited until now to protest about the abolition of the 10% tax band?") lies in the fact that MPs of the party in government - this govt in particular - must toe the party line. Once the finance bill is approved they are free to say what they like, but the harsh treatment of potential rebels in effect means we do not have quite the level of democracy that we think we do. Unfortunately, while places like Zimbabwe continue to set the worst kind of example, we will continue to think ourselves lucky instead of questioning some of the more dubious practices within parliamentary politics.
Complain about this post
Why not interview the former May 1968
student activist Daniel Cohn-Bendit
(now a French MEP) about the Olympic
Games in China and the torch ......?
Dany made a blistering speech in the
European Parliament about this on 26 March 2008 - arguing that: "We need
to kick up some dust during the Olympic Games in China".
Complain about this post
Despite much coverage on this subject, I am still very confused about the current financial crisis the world seems to be in.
I would very much like this question to be put to a financial expert: Why is it so bad if a bank (e.g. Northern Rock) goes bankrupt? It happens to other types of businesses all the time. I can't see the problem.
Complain about this post
The abolition of the 10p tax band means that for a number of poor pensioners, they have effectively had their winter heating allowance withdrawn.
Complain about this post
Can you report more about the Chinese'Men in Blue' who escorted the torch through London yesterday. According to Radio Four this morning these men were acting as a sudo police force, even against our own Met Police aswell as protestors. Have we really allowed the Chinese government to impose their own strict policing methods in our capital, indeed with their own 'police or secret service'. If so this is very sinister, and if it has occured without our governments knowledge what do they intend to do about it?
Complain about this post
Apart from the list you suggested, I think it might be time for a piece on the ethical business management of sport. I'm not just concerned about the Beijing and London Olympics, but also the FIA (Max Mosely) and the ownership of various Premiership clubs.
Come to think of it, that's probably enough for a complete series.
Complain about this post
Will the dial-eye-lama be paying for the Met Police overtime bill for a Sunday to police that circus yesterday ?
No- way gorgeous Gordon will just have it added to our council tax next year
Policing these fiascos is costing us a fortune meanwhile the crime statisics are rising. I think someone needs to think these things through in addition it caused chaos on the roads yesterday.
Complain about this post
This Labour Government,a LABOUR Government, to paraphrase Neil Kinnock's rant at Derek Hatton, in one breath says it wants to get people into work and off benefits, then penanlises those who are low paid, like my deaf son, who preferred to work at Tesco's rather than live off Disability allowances. (I am eternally grateful to them for giving him a job)
Earning less than 拢11,000 per year with overtime he is now penalised by this duplicitous Government which
then has the cheek to say that they MAY address it by, guess what, benefits!!
Added to its closing down of REMPLOY with other lies that "normal" industry will find jobs for the handicapped, none to date, no wonder back bench MP's are revolting--I would say the front bench is more revolting than they!!!??
In the light of the bloggers above I want to see EVERY MP's expenses list exposed. Why is the media and the 91热爆 backing off from this scandal?
Complain about this post
News headlines focus on Tony Blair's claim for his TV licence but his total expenses are less than 拢9,000. Cameron claims more than 拢21,000 for his mortgage in a year, which is the bigger story?
Complain about this post
Question...Will the protests stop the games? Answer No, Will the protests make China think about their postion on Tibet? No. Has any country actually got the balls to question China? No. Is this goverment going to do something about it? Guess what? No.
Complain about this post
We are told (ad nauseum) that with tax changes '..there will always be winners and losers...'
In which case:
Why engineer things so that the losers are the poorest of all: No children (any more) so little access to tax credits etc.
Why engineer things so that you make low earners so poor that they need to be receiving benefits to 'break even?
If HMG need more cash why take the money from those with least so that the better off can have more?
Govt. advertisements say that families can qualify for Child-Tax-Credits even with family incomes of over 拢50,000 ! (yes, really) and this government is taking money from people poor but proud enough to want to work.
The usual lazy, incompetence or an agenda (more benefit-serfs means more voters)?
No chance of a change of policy without an change of regime. I feel betrayed!
John B
Redditch
Complain about this post
WARS AND RUMOURS OF WARS
The whole subject of politician鈥檚 behaviour and their relationship with, and to 鈥渄emocracy鈥, is highlighted by various postings above. Politicians decry referenda yet, although impractical, a referendum on every issue is as close to 鈥済overnment by the people鈥 as we can get. Indeed, my MP labours under the illusion that he was elected as a 鈥減erson鈥 with the approval of the electorate; appearing not to know that he was a 鈥渞osette stand鈥 at the 2005 election. It seems the defining mind-set of 鈥渢he politician鈥 is 鈥渆ither a fool or a knave鈥 鈥 some managing both at once! Brown鈥檚 recent dance between whipped and free votes, over the 鈥淟ife Gordon, but not as we know it鈥 issue, is just a further departure from anything approaching democracy. At the root of all this nonsense (and other problems like funding and various voting iniquities) lies THE PARTY SYSTEM. I have heard worthies such as Hazel Blears declare with great aplomb: 鈥淵ou have to have parties!鈥 Hello! Hazel! I bring news love. Much of the wasted time and money and most of the lies and chicanery, are in the name of 鈥渢he party鈥; that must be protected and revered. The fact that some diffident and belated reactionaries are now actualy rearing up, shows just how bad things are!
So Newsnight, if you are over the nasty fright of The War of Gilligan鈥檚 Ear鈥, I invite you to get the usual suspects in to answer the question: 鈥淲hat have parties to do with democracy?鈥 What if you lose a few 91热爆 grandees? I鈥檒l be cheering!
SPOIL PARTY GAMES
Complain about this post
I would like to see the protesters interviewed; what degree of understanding do they really have of Chinese politics and the issues of Tibet; what are their motivations for the protest; are their protest as much about needing to find a political voice on something / anything?; why are people so keen to jump on anti-Chinese bandwagons? Is there something inherently anti-Chinese built into our establishments?
Complain about this post
Dear Liz
If you are going on the 10p income tax issue, you may be interested to know that Gordon Brown is doing a live webcast at 7pm. As chair of Save the Labour Party I am asking if we can get a straight-forward Labour answer which will work on the doorstep.
This will also be a test of Labour's readiness to embrace new media. So I have posted my question and look forward to seeing the live event. It will be very interesting to see whether the questions put to the PM reflect current issues.
Complain about this post
If the government are that short of cash and have to claw money back from the lower paid, how about leaving the E.U. That would give us approx. 拢40bn a year to spend on key areas such as nursing, pensions and police officers.
Far better than paying a load of unelected crooks in Brussels.
Complain about this post
"Chinese torch protests - how can we move this on?"
Quire simply - get all the old anti-apartheid campaigners like Hain in and ask them why "politics must be kept out of sport" now.
Lawson - just ignore him as he messed up the economy last time round.
Complain about this post
to anon (above. im sure plenty of the protestors have at least some knowledge of what they're protesting about otherwise they wouldnt bother. just because people are not always involved in politics does not mean they do not understand it. as far as the "anti-chinese" asumption you make its just that. an asumption. its movement against the government not the people. thats the whole point. Why would people waste their time protesting for better human rights if they were anti-anybody. it wouldnt make sense. If there are no issues in China why havent we heard their side? and why is there a ban on western media?
Complain about this post
Not a drop of oil, a whiff of gas nor a lump of coal will be left in the ground if needed to sustain an economy. Climate change will be eventually limited by the running down of the carboniferous fuels. All oils, including tarsands are expected to peak in 2010, natural gas in 2020 with coal soon after in 2040. It is the reduction in the efficiency of extracting resources which is the real problem we face.
Complain about this post
JUst a thought on the postings above over protests.
Human rights? When are we going to see the same "professional protesters" (Not Tibetans) take the streets against Mugabe and the way he treats his people in that country. Not much different than the Chinese.
Complain about this post
Hi, I would like to see the 91热爆 take a stand on their news coverage and report the full story rather than keep trying to compete with the private channels for the best headline grabbing headline ??
Quite often they could take the high-ground so to speak and not just report a headline grabbing statement but actually take the time to look into both sides of the same story and report an unbiased balanced view so most people could understand the real news item. This would in my view perhaps go towards justification for the licence fee.
As i am sure there is a lot more information regarding the Chinese/Tibet situation than just the headlines and the same goes for Zimbabwe, so please take the time and trouble to provide us with a fuller story on these and other situation, rather than just headlines which are then perhaps followed up by more detailed programs some weeks or months after the event.
Complain about this post
The Diana verdict.
Did you think that the verdict would be any different? 3 jurors did NOT agree. Why not?
Did you think that any verdict would go against the establishment? Just look at all these people (including the French Police) that refused to give evidence.
I repeat....this was a "majority" verdict...by not means conclusive.
Complain about this post
BA - people go to jail for long periods on majority jury verdicts. Legally, it's regarded as pretty conclusive.
Complain about this post
TEN PENCE TAX
What aload of lies tonight from Brown, Carter and the Treasury.
Ishall be deducting another 拢25 yearly from my Council Tax ,Believe me.---Barbara Norwich
Complain about this post
What I wouldn't like to see is the 91热爆 giving Nigel Lawson a platform to promote his new book and put forward his ridiculous views about climate change.
Wikipedia -
Corporate roles
2007: Chairman of Central European Trust (CET). Clients include: American Express, Bank of America Barclays, BNP Paribas, BP Amoco, Bristol-Myers Squibb, British Telecom, CGNU, Cygna, Cisco Systems, Coca Cola, Compaq Computers, Dow Chemical, E.I. du Pont de Nemours,General Electric, Glaxo Smith Kline,k GTE, IBM,Lehman Brothers Holdings, Lockheed Martin, Merck, Microsoft, Mitsui, Nestl茅, PepsiCo, Procter & Gamble, Royal Dutch/Shell Group, Sara Lee, SBC Communications, Soci茅t茅 G茅n茅rale, Sun Microsystems, Texaco, Total Fina Elf, Unilever, Xerox, Yamanouchi. (CET Website)
2007: Chairman of Oxford Investment Partners (OXIP Website)
2002: Non Executive Director NM Rothschild (Reference
Complain about this post
NATURE RULES.During cold war the scientists warned us about a nuclear winter.
After krakatoa "GLOBAL temperatures plummeted not recovering until well into the 20th.century".This was slowed by nuclear testing and industrial activity.
Scientists acknowledge that both California and Vesuvius are overdue ??
Complain about this post